> Franz Joseph Haydn - The Seasons [JL]: Classical CD Reviews- Jun2002 MusicWeb(UK)

One of the most grown-up review sites around
One of the most grown-up review sites around

Search MusicWeb Here


International mailing

Up to 40% off

  Founder: Len Mullenger

MusicWeb is now part of See what else is on offer

Franz Joseph HAYDN (1732-1809)
The Seasons (highlights)
Gundula Janowitz, Werner Hollweg, Walter Berry
Chorus of the Deutsche Oper, Berlin
Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra/Herbert von Karajan
Recorded Berlin, 1972
EMI CLASSICS CDE 574977 2 [53:26]


AmazonUK   AmazonUS

I am sure you have come across the sort of person who stops a conversation in its tracks by making a comment on the subject under discussion that is provocatively contrary to received wisdom. It is usually designed to impress. I will give you a musical example. Imagine a few friends discussing Elgar's The Dream of Gerontius after attending a performance and someone claims the experience has just confirmed to them what a masterpiece it is. Then one of the party chips in with, "Well I have to say I still regard The Kingdom as the greater work". Now it is probable that none of the others present is in a position to challenge this (which no doubt is the intention) since they may not be familiar with Elgar's lesser known oratorio.

Imagine a similar scenario but exchange Gerontius for Haydn's Creation and there will be a know-all who will say, "well actually I consider The Seasons a greater work", (or they may say "Die Jahreszeiten " hoping that no one else can pronounce it, or preferably hasn't heard of it).

It is becoming increasingly fashionable to claim that The Seasons contains a higher proportion of top rate Haydn than The Creation. Take scholar/pianist Charles Rosen, for example. "In neither The Creation nor The Seasons is the high level of writing always as successfully and as continuously sustained as in the great symphonies and quartets (although the less admired Seasons seem to me more successful in this respect)". He then adds, by the way, the throw-a-way remark, ".. but they are among the greatest works of the century".

If you believe Rosen then it follows that The Creation would lend itself more to a highlights approach than The Seasons. But if we take a more old fashioned view of The Seasons: Roger Fiske, for example, writing forty years ago - "The Seasons does not stand up to complete performance, partly because the recitatives grow wearisome as one’s indifference to the fate of Jane, Lucas, and Simon increases" - then clearly, selective highlighting is the solution. Fiske touches on The Seasons’ problem; its plot. The Creation, with its divinely directed apocalyptic events has a sure, lofty sense of progression from chaos to order. The Seasons, on the other hand, is a cyclically seasonal tale of simple country folk, a sort of Lower Austrian Archers.

Either way, this highlights reissue, first put out in 1975, three years after the recording of the complete work, would be a way of ensuring you can hear the best bits. So imagine my surprise when it failed to include the very opening (Spring) which is a superbly developed orchestral section invoking Winter-Spring transition followed by the succinct introduction of the three protagonists in quick order. The entry of Hanne ("Jane"), as she welcomes the warm Spring breezes is exquisite. We get none of that. Without this scene-setter it is clear that the approach is not to be a summary of the work. But it misses out some of the best music (the wonderful sunrise in Summer is also cut, would you believe) and there is a fair amount of recitative, the sort of thing Roger Fiske was moaning about. Consequently I failed to discern the rationale behind the compilation.

Nevertheless there are splendid things to be heard, not least of all Gundula Janowitz who is the trump card in this Karajan performance as she was in her earlier recording with Karl Böhm and the Vienna Symphony Orchestra. There is a timbre to Janowitz’s voice that is quite unlike any other soprano that I have ever heard. It has an airy, reedy quality that makes it perfect for the outdoor pastoralism of The Seasons. On this disc we have to wait until Summer to hear her, but it is worth waiting for. In the aria, Haydn has Hanne responding to the symbolic optimism of Summer in a way that is, at the same time, both spiritual and sensually earthy. As in her initial entry that I referred to earlier, he has her dialoguing with an oboe (the orchestra’s most pastoral member), an instrument that perfectly matches Janowitz’s unique sound. If you were to listen to this after hearing her in the Böhm version then it makes Karajan’s way with this music sound hopelessly over indulgent. I would guess he takes it 30% slower than Böhm but it is possible to be seduced by the romantic sound of the Berlin Orchestra and the oboe soloist is so intoxicating as to be in danger of upstaging Janowitz.

If you enjoy the Karajan/Berlin sound then there is much to delight and excite on this disc, the blazing hunting horns in Autumn being one of many examples.

There must be comfortably over a third of the whole work represented here. Bearing in mind my comments above, my advice would be: why not buy the whole thing? There are some fine recorded performances but if you want Janowitz then her earlier version is available on CD and Böhm is more springy than Karajan, keeping up a momentum that not only is more suited to complete performance but better matches the subject matter.

John Leeman


Return to Index

Untitled Document

Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.