One of the most grown-up review sites around

54,928 reviews
and more.. and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here



International mailing

Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             



Karel Ancerl Volume 1
Joseph HAYDN (1732-1809)

Symphony No 93 in D (1791)
Franz SCHUBERT (1797-1828)

Symphony No 9 in C D944 Great (1825-28)
Antonin DVOŘÁK (1841-1904)

Slavonic Dances Opp 46 and 72 (1878 and 1886)
Nicolai RIMSKY-KORSAKOV (1844-1908)

Scheherazade Op 35 (1888)
Sergei PROKOFIEV (1891-1953)

Romeo and Juliet Op 64 – excerpts (1938)
Berlin Radio Symphony Orchestra except
Gewandhaus Orchestra Leipzig (Prokofiev)
Karel Ancerl
Recorded from radio broadcasts 1957-1961
TAHRA TAH 117-119
[3 CDs 206.19]

Tahra has kept Ancerl’s admirers on their toes for a number of years now and this 1995 triple CD box was a prestigious affair. It mined East German radio broadcast material made between 1957-61 principally with the Berlin Radio Symphony Orchestra (though the Prokofiev was made with the Leipzig Gewandhaus).

The central panel of the set, disc number two, is entirely given over to familiar Ancerl territory, Dvořák, and yet not quite so. Recorded over three days in June 1960 we have both sets of Slavonic Dances, opp 46 and 72 – the more famous of which, op 46, can be judged against Ancerl’s commercial Supraphon recording and the less comprehensively known, op 72 – which Ancerl never recorded commercially – can most easily be contrasted with the live concert in Wellington the previous year given by the triumphant Czech Philharmonic during their Australasian tour, a performance also issued by Tahra. In truth neither traversal here, though there are numerous affectionate felicities, quite measures up to the competition. I liked the Berlin orchestra’s romantic wind playing and the many points of overlapping string lines, the bounce and vigour, the frequent sharply accented paragraphs, the fresh air approach; The third of the op 46 set has delicious wind playing and the violin pointing in the fourth is splendid; but the strings are not flattered by the studio acoustic and there is a lack of opulence that, whilst good for clarification of sectional writing, is less good for weight of romantic impress and the unforced geniality the music needs. In the Op 72 set the magical ebullience of the Wellington performance can’t be replicated in the studio; that evening was punctuated by delighted applause and whilst Ancerl and the Berlin orchestra are committed and strongly athletic and bring gusto to the scores, once more a frisson is missing.

The set actually opens with a pairing of Haydn and Schubert from two concerts in 1957 and prime candidates for Tahra’s retrievals since these are not composers at least much known commercially from the Ancerl discography. I like the strong, sinewy first movement of his Haydn, the unvarnished phrasing of the slow movement with its nice swells and diminuendos. He’s no prude when it comes to the bassoon joke either. He takes the minuet at a good brisk lick and despite a few seconds of rather strange distortion at the beginning of the finale he offers an enjoyable and frequently vivacious reading without distortions or point making. It’s not a revelatory reading but it’s hardly a negligible one either. Equally satisfying is the Schubert – good piping woodwinds in the opening movement, a sense of genuine symphonic momentum realized, alert rhythms and lean cello sonority. The Andante is realized as the tempo indicates con moto – this is no congealing Andante-as-Largo – and is it my ears hearing what they want to hear or does Ancerl manage to elicit just a smidgen of Bohemian folk vigour here? There is something almost Mahlerian in Ancerl’s hands about the oppositional character of the Scherzo … and the finale goes nicely indeed. There were two performances of the symphony given on consecutive nights in December 1957 but as to which was used in this performance Tahra is silent.

The final disc is given over to the Russian repertoire of which Ancerl was so adept and idiomatic an interpreter. Two heavyweight works are given, Scheherazade and Romeo and Juliet (premiered, it’s often forgotten, in Brno in 1938). The former was once more given on two nights in January 1957, the latter from a single concert four years later. The leader of the Berlin orchestra has an opportunity to shine. With his quick portamenti and control of dynamics he acquits himself well. The brass is solid; strings are clean limbed and clear, not opulent. I enjoyed Ancerl’s big spaced drama in the second movement – though he’s never going to approach Kletzki’s well calibrated strength here - and the playful expressivity he imparts to the Young Prince and Princess. At various points the balance seems slightly awry – particularly in the final movement – but it’s of barely any account. I don’t have Ancerl’s commercially issued Romeo and Juliet but Tahra’s notes aver that in their November 1961 performance in Leipzig he adds three scenes here that were omitted in the Supraphon disc. There’s plenty of bite and romance here and the Gewandhaus Orchestra dig in with vigour but with their characteristic refinement as well.

Notes are in French and Italian only, with some splendid vintage photographs as well. For once the relatively familiar shot of Ancerl looking happily absurd in a kimono is eclipsed by one of him with Alois Haba posed by what looks like one of Haba’s scary looking quarter-tone keyboards. As for the music – strongly recommended.

Jonathan Woolf

Return to Index

Untitled Document

Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.