Transcriptions for the guitar of the works of Johann Sebastian
Bach, have for the most part been limited to the Cello Suites and the
Sonatas and Partitas for solo violin. These have supplemented the small
number of pieces for lute that Bach composed a treasury which has been
the source of such valuable material for guitarists. Some evidence suggests
that the Lautenclavicymel (lute-harpsichord) a harpsichord with gut rather
than metal strings may have been Bach’s intended instrument for these
works.
Although this disc does include the "Violin Sonata",
BWV 1001, for me it is the transcriptions of keyboard works that hold
the most interest as they are a more unusual source of Bach’s music
to play on the guitar.
Guitarist Enno Voorhorst, who not only plays but also
has transcribed all the pieces on this recording himself, does a good
job of capturing the essence of Bach. Particularly fine is the "Harpsichord
Concerto", BWV 974 (itself a reworking of the Oboe Concerto by
Alessandro Marcello) as are "Prelude in E Major", BWV 854
and "Prelude in C (A) major", BWV 939, two works I have never
heard on the guitar before.
The opening piece on the disc is the "Partita
in A minor", BWV 1013 for solo flute, I recall this being performed
by David Russell some years ago and like Russell’s transcription Enno
Voorhorst accommodates the work eminently well, augmenting it with added
harmony to broaden the texture.
Enno Voorhorst’s playing of these works is convincingly
stylish, even though at times the difficulty factor is apparent and
string squeaks are a little obtrusive. However, this still remains an
interesting and enjoyable disc.
As a point of interest this CD was not recorded in
Naxos’s usual venue for guitar recordings, that being St Chrysostom
Church, Newmarket, Ontario, Canada with producer Norbert Kraft, but
at the Hervormde Kerk, Rensoude, Netherlands under Bert van de Wolf
and although the sound is very good it seems to lack the lustre achieved
by Kraft.
Andy Daly