> ADAM La Filleule des Fées [WH]: Classical CD Reviews- Aug 2002 MusicWeb(UK)

One of the most grown-up review sites around

54,928 reviews
and more.. and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here



International mailing

Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             

MusicWeb is now part of http://www.classicallink.com See what else is on offer

Adolphe ADAM (1803-1856)
La Filleule des Fées (1849)
Queensland Symphony Orchestra/Andrew Mogrelia
Recorded in 1996 at the ABC Studio, Brisbane, Australia.
MARCO POLO 8.223734/5 [2CDs: 67.52+58.41]


AmazonUK   AmazonUS


Adolphe Adam was born in Paris in 1803, the same year as Berlioz. Most record collectors will know him as the composer of the ballet Giselle, but he was very much more than that, being both a respected teacher and an influential music critic, not to mention the small matter of the seventy or so operas he composed.

La Filleule des Fées (‘The Fairies’ Goddaughter’) is a full-length ballet which was first seen at the Paris Opera. It was apparently quite a success, though the booklet notes draw greater attention to innovative features of the staging than to the music, which, even for 1849, was conservative in style and would not have frightened the horses. It’s interesting to speculate, therefore, quite what he and Berlioz, whose paths must certainly have crossed on more than one occasion, thought of each other!

The story begins at the baptism of the child Ysaure and the appearance at the celebration of three old women, later to be revealed as three fairies, two good, one bad. These three, as the title suggests, become Ysaure’s unofficial godmothers, and therefore very much have a hand in what follows. And what follows is a tale of love conquering all. Ysaure has two suitors, one of whom is called Alain and the other the Prince Hugues de Provence. No contest really. In fact things turn out to be quite difficult, especially since the bad fairy decides to save her baptismal gift until Ysaure’s fifteenth birthday. As is the way with wicked fairies the gift turns out to be a mixed blessing: she makes Ysaure so beautiful that any man who looks at her, including the Prince, goes mad. One way round this sorry state of affairs is to strike the Prince blind, but this of course is hardly the ideal solution either, and so, with the intervention of the good fairies an agreement is made that if the Prince can recognise Ysaure amongst all the girls present at a given moment his sight and sense will be restored. Somehow the different parties contrive to bring the pair so close to each other that their hearts beat in unison, and the Prince, of course, recognises her immediately. Who wouldn’t? Prior to this Ysaure has, amongst other adventures, ridden on a swan and spent a short time as a statue. As for poor Alain, he seems to lose out to the aristocracy at every turn, but he’s a decent chap, and when he sees how happy Ysaure and the Prince are, he is happy in his turn.

A detailed synopsis is printed in the booklet, and following the story whilst listening to the music is a simple matter. That said, there’s very little attempt at characterisation, beyond a certain number of stock gestures to differentiate good from evil, for example. And then you know there are hunters about even without the synopsis because you hear their horn calls amid jolly galloping music in six/eight time. Odd moments of suspense are underlined by chromatic movement in the bass.

Other composers come to mind from time to time listening to this music, the Johann Strauss of Die Fledermaus, for example, or occasionally Rossini, but not, emphatically not, Berlioz! I haven’t seen a score of this piece, but careful listening reveals little in the way of thematic development beyond having them played again with different interludes, sometimes with the orchestration varied, sometimes not. The orchestral writing is often quite effective, however, in particular the use of the woodwind. But there are too many grand fanfares to introduce new dances, and too many big finishes that other composers would be happy to use at the end of a huge symphony. After a while you get tired of all those repeated cymbal crashes on strong beats too. The structure starts to reveal itself after a while, and many of the themes return, but, as previously stated, without much in the way of development. Nor are the themes themselves always of enough interest or character to make us altogether happy to hear them again.

You can certainly see the dance in your mind’s eye when you listen to this music, and I’m quite sure that as an accompaniment to dance the music is well crafted. There are passages in all ballets, and in operas too for that matter, where the emotional temperature is allowed to drop a little; in Swan Lake or The Sleeping Beauty, in Ma mère l’Oye or The Prince of the Pagodas. And this is perfectly natural: the eventfulness of the music must be geared, after all, to the events it accompanies. But here these passages are not alleviated by others of outstanding inspiration and beauty as they are in Tchaikovsky’s masterpieces, for example. And I know we shouldn’t always compare with the finest examples of a given form. I’m merely doing so here to underline my own reaction to this music which seems to me to be particularly bland and uninspired.

There can be no complaints at all about the production values of this set, however. The booklet is informative and well written, and the performance itself is excellent. The Queensland Symphony Orchestra play extremely well under conductor Andrew Mogrelia, but they can only find in the music what there is in it to find, and the poor second violins and violas can hardly have had a riveting few days recording this.

Perhaps listeners more attuned to dance than I am will be able to hear more in this issue than I did. In any case, I urge them to try it, as the efforts of all concerned should be recognised. I do wonder, however, if the music justified the effort involved.

William Hedley

Return to Index

Untitled Document

Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.