> STRONG Le Roi Arthur 8559048 [RB]: Classical Reviews- April2002 MusicWeb(UK)

One of the most grown-up review sites around

54,928 reviews
and more.. and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here



International mailing

Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             

George Templeton STRONG (1856-1948)
Die Nacht - four little tone poems (1913) [26.10]
Le Roi Arthur - symphonic poem (1916) [40.56]
Moscow SO/Adriano
rec April 1999, Mosfilm Studios, Moscow
world premiere recordings
NAXOS 8.559048 [67.15]


Crotchet   AmazonUK   AmazonUS

Adriano tells us, in his detailed programme note, that the works of Strong were recommended to him by Ernest Ansermet whom he met in 1967. Later a friend added sparks and smoke to the kindling with a tape of Toscanini's broadcast of Die Nacht (21 October 1939). When a large cache of Strong's scores came into Adriano's possession in the early 1990s the seal was well and truly set.

Strong went to Leipzig in 1879 to study with Jadassohn and then fell in with Liszt and his Weimar circle. There he came under the thrall of programme music. He lived in Germany for much of his late youth there meeting Edward MacDowell whose (much more concise) orchestral music can be seen as a parallel. After a brief visit to the USA in 1891-2 he returned to Europe residing then in Switzerland. The Flonzaley quartet played his music. In 1930, eighteen years before his death he donated most of his scores to the Library of Congress despite his indignation about the rejection of his music by American orchestras. The symphonic suite Une Vie d'Artiste (another Heldenleben, I wonder) was premiered at the 20th Festival of the Association of Swiss Musicians. This was in June 1920. It is scored for violin and orchestra. Strong's home during his Swiss years was at Vevey on Lake Geneva where he became increasingly drawn to watercolour paintings. (I wonder if any have survived - if so they might be used as the cover for later instalments in this series). Strong founded the Société Vaudoise des Aquarellistes.

Die Nacht can best be thought of as a tone poem in four movements. The movements are: At Sunset, Peasant's Battle March, In an Old Forest and The Awakening of the Forest-Spirits. The music is at its most accomplished and communicative in the Sunset and Old Forest (I and III) episodes. Here Strong is ruminative and mysterious. He falls prey to raucous temptations in the Peasant's March (where the orchestra's polish noticeably lapses) and in The Awakening. The rough-edged gangling march is apt in its awkward edges. The Awakening has more successful music than not. Stylistically speaking, with this work, we are at the delta of influences from Berlioz (there is some extremely colourful and imaginative writing especially in the final episode), Liszt, Dukas, Mendelssohn (faerie music) and Wagner (Walküre in The Awakening). Raff is another reference point though Strong is much better at sustaining mystery and mood.

The Arthurian Legends have spawned a wide range of music. Examples include Chausson's opera Le Roi Arthus and his tone poem Viviane, Ropartz's 1912 tone poem Le Chasse du Prince Arthus, Rutland Boughton's cycle of Arthurian operas (most never performed), Albert Coates' Lancelot and Elaine symphony. Macdowell's Lancelot and Elaine, Merlin operas by Goldmark, Albeniz, Ladmirault and Inglis Gundry, Elinor Remick Warren in her Legend of King Arthur and fellow American Louis Coerne's tone poem Excalibur recorded by Karl Krueger on MIA141 in long departed LP days.

There is some delightfully Straussian or even Mahlerian succulent horn writing at 6.10 in the first of the three movements. This music also taxes the orchestra who hold onto coordination by the skin of their teeth. The slow tread of the adagio-andante is reminiscent of a rather primeval Mahler. The suggestion of disarming innocence amid the eldritch is strong. It is a small step from the Erben-based works of Dvorak and Fibich to this music. Dvorak and Fibich are, however, more concentrated and succinct. The music is much stronger in the finale where the tragic legacy of betrayal by Lancelot and by Guinevere breathes in music of the considerable mastery worthy at last of Strong's ambitious reach.

Though not so labelled, this is the second volume in Naxos's Strong Edition. It will encompass the complete orchestra works in the fullness of time.

This disc was sponsored by the Czeslaw Marek Foundation of Zürich.

There are three symphonies in all. No. 1 is In den Bergen; No. 2 is Sintram (recorded by Adriano and in LP days by Karl Krueger) and No. 3 An der See. Grove 5 (yes, that's two editions back - I have not checked the latest Grove) tells us that the First Symphony was successfully played in the States and in Europe. Other works we can hope will be among Adriano's schedule include the symphonic poem, Undine, a symphonic idyll An der Nixenquelle as well as pieces for soli, chorus and orchestra: Knights and Dryads, Wie ein fahrender Hornist sich ein Land erblies and Die Verlassene Mühle.

The first volume (NAXOS 8.559018) was reviewed here in January 2000. It included the second recording ever of Strong's Sintram Symphony and Hassler Chorale. When I reviewed this I said that I awaited the second volume with the keenest curiosity. Well, roll on the third disc.

I rather hope that someone can volunteer to me a list of Strong's works with dates and if possible dates and details of premieres.

These are pleasingly discursive late-romantic canvases which sit easily with the pictorial works of Raff, and Huber.

Rob Barnett

Return to Index

Untitled Document

Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.