> LEGEND - Danish Double Bass DACOCD593 [JF]: Classical Reviews- April2002 MusicWeb(UK)

One of the most grown-up review sites around

54,928 reviews
and more.. and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here



International mailing

Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             

LEGEND - Late Romantic Danish Works for double bass and piano
Ludvig Hegner (1851-1923)

Legende Op.5 (1896)
Nocturne Op.6
Trois Morceaux
Mazurka de concert

Franz Neruda (1843-1915)

Berceuse Slave (1881)
Louis Glass (1864-1936)

Nocturne Op.33 (1902)
Per Dalsgaard Knudsen: double bass
Karsten Munk: piano
Recorded Musikhuset Sonderborg, Denmark, June/August 2001.

Let us deal with the positive things about this CD first of all. It is a typical Danacord production in so far as it is well packaged, nice to look at and hold, excellent programme notes and a good 65 minutes of playing time. Also typical is their courage in presenting an entire CD of works that are unrecorded and practically unknown, except to specialists, all composed for double bass and piano. And here we locate the problem; over an hour of double bass sound is difficult to handle. Bassists would argue, of course, that it is too much of an excellent thing. I would suggest that the problem is that all the pieces seem to blend into one. Somehow, in spite of the obviously superb and highly competent playing by both the soloists this CD leaves me cold. In spite of the fact that it is all late romantic music, full of fairly intense passages and complex string figurations it is all actually rather lacklustre. Some of the music seems, to this listener, to be somewhat banal. But that perhaps is the problem with an instrument that is little composed for – performers will clutch at straws. The sifting process does not take place as it would with works composed for more popular instruments.

There is, of course, a strategy for listening to a CD like this – that is quite simply to pick out one piece, listen to it and then move onto something that is not composed for double bass and piano.

Two of the three composers represented on this CD are unknown quantities - at least to me. However, I feel we ought to be on safer ground with Louis Glass. At least he is being rediscovered both in Denmark and much further afield. Here the programme notes are excellent – just the way I love them. In fact it took me as long to read and digest 'em as it did to listen to the Nocturne Op 33. Amongst other things the notes give an extensive editorial résumé of the historical provenance of the score. But even here it does not seem to be Glass at his best. It is an acceptable piece, which probably deserves an occasional airing. However at eight minutes long it does seem to outstay its welcome. It is finely played with lots of expression and well-controlled dynamics. The central section is possibly the most original and most exciting music on this CD. Yet somehow it all seems contrived. If this were the one and only piece of Glass I had heard, I would not be moved to explore much further.

Franz Xaver Victor Neruda was born in Brno in 1843. He was a Bohemian cellist who initially earned his living largely by playing music with his father and two sisters. He was a member of the Royal Orchestra at Copenhagen and latterly the director of the musical society in that city. He finally moved to Stockholm to pursue a similar role. He seems to have written a fair amount of music, including a cello concerto, some string quartets and many piano pieces. He is credited with many works for the cello.

The present piece, the Berceuse Slav was originally composed for three cellos. It is another of these totally average pieces which must have been heard in salons the length and breadth of Europe at that time. Nothing fundamentally wrong with it, except that it is hardly a lullaby as the title implies.

The main bulk of this CD is devoted to seven works by the Copenhagen composer Ludwig Hegner. The programme notes devote some two thousand words to a description of this gentleman’s life and works. His main claim to fame, however, is that he was the first double bass teacher in Denmark. A brief perusal of the New Grove found only one reference to him and no specific article. There is nothing that I can find on the Internet; only a listing in Danacord’s catalogue! So the programme notes are the only real source of information we have on this composer.

In a nutshell, then, he was born in 1851 in the capital city and spent his career in various forms of music making – as a performer, a teacher and a composer. He played the piano and the violin, but it was to be with the double bass that he marked out his career.

The music by Hegner presented on this CD is difficult to classify. There are seven works with a total of nine pieces. As I remarked earlier, they are of a sameness. I cannot help feeling that Hegner churned out music to fit his own and his pupils' requirements. It is like so much music that has been written over the centuries - fundamentally sound but not inspired. The balance of parts and formal principles seems to me to be accomplished. It is just that each and every piece presented here lacks pizzazz and, frankly, interest.

The playing is excellent; revealing possibilities in double bass technique that I would hardly have credited. One almost regards double bass solo music with the same sense of humour as tuba music; it has the potential for being comical. There is nothing of the ridiculous here, though. It certainly puts the double bass on the map as an expressive and even warmly romantic instrument.

As a specialist CD it will appeal to a very limited range of listeners. For this I imagine Danacord do not apologise. Apart from the sameness of all these pieces and their prevailing salon feel this is a good example of niche marketing.

John France


Return to Index

Untitled Document

Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.