Classical Editor: Rob Barnett                               Founder Len Mullenger:

Gideon KLEIN, Pavel HAAS, Rudolf KAREL, Stepan LUCKY
Chamber Compositions

Rudolf Karel
Nonet op 43
Stepan Lucky (b 1919)
Divertimento for Wind Quintet
Pavel Haas (1899-1944)
Wind Quintet op 10
Gideon Klein (1919-1945)
Academia Wind Quintet Prague
Jiri Marsalek flute
Otto Trnka oboe
Petr Donek clarinet
Frantisek Pok French horn
Josef Janda bassoon
Members of the Panocha Quartet (Pavel Zejfart violin Miroslav Sehnoutka viola Jaroslav Kulhan cello) and Pavel Nejtek double bass
Members of the Czech Philharmonic Orchestra/Vladimir Valek conductor
Recorded 22 March-6 May 1997, Prague
SUPRAPHON SU 3339-2 131 [60.06]

  AmazonUS  $15.49
 Amazon recommendations

The Star of David flutters, recognisable but distorted and fractured, on the cover of Supraphon's booklet. Inside are four works by composers whose lives were each fractured or ended in the Second World War.

Rudolf Karel was one of Dvorák's last pupils at the National Conservatoire in Prague. Much of his life anticipates the trajectory of those of his fellow composers here; caught in Russia in the First World War he spent his years there in the Information Division of the Austro-Hungarian, later Czechoslovak, force. Returning home he became a professor of composition at his old conservatoire and began a series of adventurous works, somewhat austere, polyphonic and Regerian, which later softened into a more simplified style.

Karel was imprisoned for resistance activities in 1943 and eventually transferred to Terezin in February 1945, where he died the following month. Supraphon's notes are exceptionally unhelpful, telling us next to nothing about any of the works and giving a bare minimum of biographical information and so the textual complexities surrounding Karel's Nonet are nowhere addressed. As I understand it the Nonet was composed between January and February 1945 in the most distressing circumstances and left incomplete after Karel's death from dysentery on 6 March 1945. Frantisek Hertl completed the Nonet's instrumentation for a first performance on 21 December 1945. Many years later Vaclav Snitl completed a new orchestration, in 1984, for a performance by the Czech Nonet in 1985. I can only assume that it is Snitl's edition that is played on this disc.

The work itself shows few overt signs of its terrible compositional history and one can only wonder at the sixty-five year old composer's fortitude. Karel integrates the string and wind quintets with practised skill; magically he allows the violin to cut through the instrumentation in the Andante in a passionate reflection tinged with intimations of regret. In the opening movement he makes great play of affecting string writing alternating with exposed horn and clarinet passages. The third movement begins as a Czech dance, led by the upper voices, the horn and bassoon underpinning the texture. A reminiscence of the first movement leads towards a rather staccato but not inappropriate conclusion.

Never over-emphatic, neither raging nor despairing, this is a work of almost heroic simplicity; a composer knowing himself to be at the end of his life, looking back through the complexities of his compositional middle-period to his radiant uncomplicated youth.

Stepan Lucky was born in Zilina in 1919 into what was then newly independent Czechoslovakia and what is now Slovakia. As with Karel, Lucky was active in the resistance - and in the Slovak Uprising of 1944 - and was sent to Auschwitz and Buchenwald. After the War he studied with Ridky and Haba and began a career as a forward-thinking composer before emerging as one of the Republic's leading film composers. The Divertimento dates from 1974 and with its busy clarinet and flute writing it wears a rather puckish Prokofiev-like cut; a very folkish clarinet episode leads to the now pliant clarinet being joined by oboe and flute as they gently end the alla marcia. Lucky writes a rather crepuscular slow movement and a light-but-involved scherzo finale. This is a short but welcome addition to the repertoire and written in the best traditions of Czech and Slovak wind writing.

Haas and Klein are the best known of the composers and we can judge their works with a certain objective detachment because the op. 10 Quintet of Haas dates from 1929 and the Klein, though written in 1940, precedes his incarceration in Terezin. Haas's piece is deliciously witty. Beginning with a rather insistent rising and falling theme with chirping runs and brilliant French horn writing it discloses an increasingly expressive Preghiera which flirts with Stravinsky. The Balo eccentrico is just that with an impish dance and thwarted attempts to lyricise the theme - a delightfully witty exhausted slumping signals the effort involved. The finale is clear-eyed, somewhat stern and withdrawn before opening out fully into a neo-baroque conclusion tinged with chromaticism. Throughout, something of Janacek's influence can be felt and Haas' own description of the 1920-22 Brno master classes, which Janacek led, and Haas attended, could equally apply to the younger composer; "His short sentences were often glaringly contradictory, and yet his powers of persuasion were as strong as his beliefs."

Once again the notes don't tell us but Klein's Divertimento is written for two oboes, two clarinets, two bassoons and two French horns. They are played by members of the Czech Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by Vladimir Valek. It is a fractious and angular piece and flirts with elements of atonality. With its emphasis on polyphony this is an exceptionally astute work for a twenty-one year old. Saturated as it is in Moravian folk song influence the adagio in particular burgeons under Klein's sophisticated harmonic textures; the variation form he employs in such a short span of time - barely five minutes - is especially noteworthy as is the Janacek theme (from The Diary of One who Disappeared) and its subsequent development.

The performances here are all deeply impressive. The Academia Wind Quintet Prague, in particular, is an outstanding group whose expressive, technical and stylistic qualities lend distinction to the music and to this disc.

Jonathan Woolf

Return to Index

Reviews from previous months
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board.  Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.This is the only part of MusicWeb for which you will have to register.

You can purchase CDs, tickets and musician's accessories and Save around 22% with these retailers: