Classical Editor: Rob Barnett                               Founder Len Mullenger: Len@musicweb-international.com


Benjamin BRITTEN
Sacred and Profane, A.M.D.G., Five Flower Songs, A Hymn to the Virgin, Choral Dances from 'Gloriana', Chorale after an Old French Carol

Polyphony/Stephen Layton
HYPERION CDA 67140 [61:26]
Crotchet   AmazonUK   AmazonUS

Stephen Layton continues his series of recordings for Hyperion with this fine disc of unaccompanied choral music by Benjamin Britten. Previous composers featured have included John Rutter, Peter Cornelius, Arvo Pärt and Percy Grainger, so the arrival of this disc puts Layton and his choir of professional singers much more into the searchlight of competing versions.

In general they come through with flying colours. Britten's last work for unaccompanied chorus, Sacred and Profane (1975) receives a superb performance ahead of such rivals as The Sixteen under Harry Christophers (ex Collins Classics) and the Choir of Trinity College Cambridge under Richard Marlow (Conifer Classics). In the final setting 'A Death' Polyphony takes about thirty seconds off the timing of the other choirs (a significant amount in a piece that usually lasts a mere three minutes) and this heightened tempo increases the feeling of a helpless and remorseless charge towards death, a fate that Britten knew, for him, was not too far off. The final line (translated into modern English) is 'For the whole world I don't care one jot' and Peter Evans' description of Britten's setting displaying 'macabre nonchalance' is particularly well achieved in this performance. In Yif Ic of Luve Can Layton gives the seductive high soprano line to a solo singer which works extraordinarily well.

Another first is an additional antiphonal effect introduced into A Hymn to the Virgin. The young Britten set the Latin and English phrases in a kind of Concerto Grosso style, with the full choir and a small group of soloists alternating between them. Layton goes one stage further by placing his solo group well away from the microphones, increasing further the 'statement and comment' aspect of the work. This is highly effective.

If there are aspects worthy of criticism, they remain small ones. The printed text of O Deus, ego amo Te from A.M.D.G. mistakenly includes the word 'shining' which should read 'sinning'. Of slightly greater concern is a nagging feeling that the choir's rather 'white' tonal make-up is just too perfect for much of this music. Layton appears to have kept singers with colourful voices away from his choir in an attempt to give the greatest possible cohesiveness. Comparing Five Flower Songs to the version by The Sixteen or A.M.D.G. to the premiere recording by Terry Edwards and the London Sinfonietta Chorus (Virgin) one is struck by the musical advantages brought to the settings by sopranos and tenors (in particular) who are able to use a wider dynamic and a much stronger use of vocal colour.

Nevertheless, Polyphony is a crack choir who sing with immaculate intonation and a sure sense of internal balance. The Chorale after an Old French Carol is suitably drenched in securely sung harmonies and I have not heard the Choral Dances from "Gloriana" better done. The Temple Church acoustic is ideal. At 61:26 I was left wishing there could be more. But this is intended to be taken as a statement of approval rather than any kind of admonition.

Simon Foster

Return to Index

Reviews from previous months
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board.  Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.This is the only part of MusicWeb for which you will have to register.


You can purchase CDs, tickets and musician's accessories and Save around 22% with these retailers: