Classical Editor: Rob Barnett                               Music Webmaster Len Mullenger:


Dream Carousels
Quartet of Beasts
Six of the Bestiary
Towards Asavari 2

John Turner, recorder*
Peter Lawson, piano 2
RNCM New Ensemble/Clark Rundell
RNCM Wind Orchestra/Timothy Reynish
NMC D 068

Up to now very little of Anthony Gilbert's varied output has been available in commercial recordings. This is a rather curious situation since Gilbert's music is not without its champions. A mere handful of works are available so far: Nine or Ten Osannas for chamber ensemble (NMC D 014), Beastly Jingles for voice and small ensemble (NMC D 025), the String Quartet No.3 Super Hoqueto David (ASC CS CD 11 - BMS News 86) and two short pieces written as 80th birthday tributes to David Cox and Ian Parrott respectively. This is why the present release is most welcome for it brilliantly shows that the neglect of Anthony Gilbert's music has nothing to do either with the quality of the music or its accessibility (or lack of it).

The earliest piece is the piano concerto, in all but the name, Towards Asavari, completed in 1978. The piece, much admired by David Lumsdaine, is based on a Spring morning Raga Asavari "along with its associated poetry and paintings, and [the composer] attempted to recapture in Western terms the energy and imagery of the whole" (Anthony Gilbert). The composer did not attempt to write Indian music, though he admits that "only ghosts of the Indian techniques" have been called in. The piece is also an attempt to look for a somewhat different way of confronting a solo instrument with other groups of instruments. Towards Asavari is a beautiful work that vastly repays repeated hearings. This recording of it was well worth waiting for.

The other concertante piece in this collection is the recorder concerto Igorochki completed in 1992 and written at the request of John Turner who is the soloist in the present performance. The title has a twofold meaning: 'igorochka' is a Russian word meaning "a little thing to play" whereas the piece is also intended as a tribute to Stravinsky who died twenty years previously. The work is scored for a small ensemble of percussion (mainly metal instruments), cimbalon, guitar and string quartet. There is much playfulness here but also a great deal of imagination, invention and subtlety. A worthwhile addition to the 20th century recorder repertoire.

Dream Carousels (1989) for wind orchestra was intended as a fiftieth birthday present for Timothy Reynish who conducted the first performance in 1989 and who conducts the present performance again with the RNCM Wind Orchestra. This piece in three short movements was written when Gilbert was working on the orchestral song cycle Certain Lights Reflecting to poems by the Tasmanian Sarah Day whose words also inspired Dream Carousels. In this Gilbert joins with a number of contemporary composers in revisiting the medium of the symphonic wind band (previously known as "military band"). By so doing he managed to look afresh at the medium and to find new ways of writing for wind band while eschewing cliches of all kinds (ancient and modern). The three constrasting movements are full of imaginative scoring and again much subtlety in handling the orchestral forces.

Among the presents he received on his fiftieth birthday Gilbert received a book from Jane Manning and her husband Anthony Payne, in which Borges writes of an ancient Chinese encyclopaedia in which the animal races are broken down into fourteen categories. This book prompted Gilbert to compose what I might refer to as his "Beast Trilogy" : Quartet of Beasts, Beastly Jingles and Six of the Bestiary. In this trilogy another facet of Gilbert's music is much in evidence and one which is often absent in contemporary music: humour. Quartet of Beasts (1984), written for the very Poulenc-like combination of flute, oboe, bassoon and piano, as well as Six of the Bestiary (1985) for saxophone quartet are short suites of sometimes very short movements "that sometimes take less to play than the title does to read" (Anthony Gilbert). In these as in the delightful Beastly Jingles (1985), which forms the central part of the triptych, Gilbert displays a lighthearted sense of humour which I for one find most refreshing. These colourful pieces teeming with invention are Gilbert at his most attractive and his most accessible.

This most welcome release has really much to offer and is unreservedly recommended for it pays Gilbert a well-deserved, if belated, tribute and also sheds considerable light on Gilbert's compositional achievement.

To conclude I will simply quote from David Lumsdaine's appreciation printed in the insert notes: "The five works on this disc are all vintage Gilbert. You'll find here elegance balanced by humour, fantasy sharpened by logic, compassion informed by clarity; above all, an inventive imagination which reveals our familiar world in new and unexpected lights".

I wish I could have written this myself!

Hubert CULOT

Return to Index

Reviews from previous months

You can purchase CDs, tickets and musician's accessories and Save around 22% with these retailers: - The UK's Biggest Video Store Concert and Show tickets
Musicians accessories
Click here to visit