Classical Music classical CDs reviewed New CD reviews every day latest Classical CD releases Buy your CDs of the classics here

Classical Editor: Rob Barnett

Music Webmaster
Len Mullenger:


Symphony No.8 in C minor (1890 version/Haas)
Zurich Tonhalle Orchestra/Rudolf Kempe
SOMM (Celeste Series) SOMMCD 016-2 (2 CDs)[82'02"]
 Amazon UK 

I'm not absolutely sure how much Bruckner Kempe recorded. This Eighth is from 1971 (on LP it was on the Tudor label). There's also a Munich Philharmonic 4 & 5 2-CD set that I recently bought on the Acanta Pilz label. The Pilz transfers are poor - excessive no-noising has, frankly, buggered good sound. Now I've found pristine copies of BASF's LPs: the black discs offer excellent results to complement Kempe's notable readings and the CDs can be consigned to the bin.

I know Kempe conducted the Second and Seventh Symphonies but I don't think he recorded them. I never heard the Tudor LPs of 8 so I'm grateful to Somm for restoring what turns out to be a fine performance. Somm's transfer is good too (or as good as the source material will allow it to be). The dynamic range is restricted but the sound is open and well detailed. There are some audible edits and the climax of the slow movement brings a change of perspective.

Kempe leads a lyrical 8th and never overplays the rhetoric. This isn't a Heaven-storming rendition but one that assuredly unfolds Bruckner's grand design; sights firmly set on long-term objectives. In short this is as musical account of Bruckner's massive C minor Symphony as you will get. The playing is good without being outstanding and I would understand if some listeners found this rendition lacked gravitas. What it doesn't lack is an innate understanding of the letter of the score. To that may be added the sense of concentration with which the musicians unfurl the music.

This is one of those performances where nothing spectacular happens, no real revelations are heard, and yet one is gripped by the sheer rightness of it all. In many ways this is great conducting, Kempe displaying wise and economical leadership. If, as recorded, the Zurich Tonhalle Orchestra is penny-plain and occasionally fallible, its musicians really know what this music is about.

What I like about Kempe's manner is that nothing is forced, nothing imposed. The music grows organically and is allowed to speak for itself (and the Finale's structural imperfections are less obvious with Kempe). If you like what Bruckner says then Kempe's masterly traversal should prove very satisfying; not as a first choice necessarily but when you want to go back to the music without distraction.

Colin Anderson




Colin Anderson



Reviews from previous months

You can purchase CDs, tickets and musician's accessories and Save around 22% with these retailers : - The UK's Biggest Video Store

Concert and Show tickets


Musicians accessories

Click here to visit

Return to Index