Classical Editor: Rob Barnett
 

Music Webmaster
Len Mullenger: Len@musicweb-international.com


HANS PFITZNER (1869-1949) THE COMPLETE STRING QUARTETS ON 2 CPO CDs   Franz Schubert Quartett

 

 Pfitzner contributed significantly to the field of chamber music. His works in this medium are:-

Cello Sonata in f sharp minor (1890)
Piano Trio (1896)
Piano Quintet (1908)
Violin Sonata (1918)
Sextet (1945)

Only in the field of the string quartet was there more than one example of each grouping. He wrote four quartets and all are featured on athispair of well documented (French, English, German) CPO discs.

 

String Quartet No. 2 Op 13 in D major (1902)
String Quartet No. 4 Op 50 in C minor (1942)
Franz Schubert Quartett
rec 2-5 Feb 1993
co-production with Bayerischer Rundfunk
CPO 999 072-2 [54.01]

Save around 22% with
Crotchet
Amazon US

Pfitzner's complete orchestral music is resplendently done on five CPO discs. The company have now turned to his chamber music and with pleasantly implacable resolve seem intent on recording the complete output. The first stage is the string quartets. These two each last just under half an hour.

Pfitzner is sometimes mentioned in the same breath as Reger. In fact there is about as much in common between those two as between another pair often bracketed together (Bruckner and Mahler) in the dark ages of the 1950s and 1960s. Pfitzner is not a man to write wild and woolly mammoths of works and Max's penchant (to which he sometimes capitulates with joyous indulgence) for prolixity is not something you can associate with Pfitzner.

The two quartets stare at each other across a void of forty years: one written 12 years before the Great War and the other written in old age during World War II. Both are attractive works and the style has hardly changed over the years. The Bachian purity and Dvorák-like romance of the first movement of Op. 13 puts not a foot wrong. There is a delightful second movement with a refrain recalling Three Blind Mice, a third movement of bruising emotionalism and a finale in the spirit of some cheery German drinking song - brimming steins and all! The Op. 54 work is hooded and reserved in the first movement and in the langsam (III) assumes the Mozartian mantle of wit and dignified beauty. The finale (Allegro) is alive with a fantasy familiar from Elgar's Introduction and Allegro.

CPO's sensitivity to artistic needs is usually high. This is noted in a hundred and one little features: for example the good long gap between the end of the 1902 work and the start of the 1942 work. Documentation excellent.

Reviewer

Rob Barnett

 

 

String Quartet No. 1 in D minor (1886)
String Quartet No. 3 Op 36 in C sharp minor (1925)
Franz Schubert Quartett
rec 1-3 Feb 1993
co-production with Bayerischer Rundfunk
CPO 999 526-2
[73.17]

Save around 22% with
Crotchet
Amazon US

The D minor quartet is the work of a teenager. The first movement's debt is to Mozart and to the muscular Brahms of the first piano concerto. This is followed by a grand dance - halting, hesitant but grand nonetheless, a Bachian andante and a chuggingly affable Allegro finale.

The Op. 36 work is, in contrast, a work of Pfitzner's ripe maturity. The work is close to 40 minutes long and its epic scope translated into an orchestration as a symphony. Under this mantle it is probably better known. It is a work of great strength. The initial Ziemlich ruhig pitches and cants around the aural scenery in unbridled abandon: like sparks and brands flying out of one of Bernard van Dieren's string quartets (now there is a project for CPO) or the accompaniment to Warlock's song cycle The Curlew. The Sehr schnell is fast, ghostly - a leering nightride. The langsam third movement is a rocking Zemlinskian dream. The finale is passionate, bursting the fetters of the quartet medium and seeming to be more in the nature of a violin concerto complete with gypsy fire and searing cinders.

I look forward to later instalments of Pfitzner's accessible chamber music. Certainly recommended for the explorer - as also is the other CPO disc.

Reviewer

Rob Barnett

Reviewer

Rob Barnett


Reviews from previous months


Reviews carry sales links but you can also purchase from:

Return to Index