Classical Editor: Rob Barnett

Music Webmaster
Len Mullenger:

KARLSEN St. John Passion Op. 100     Bergen Cathedral Choir with soloists, instrumentalists/ Tor Grønn (organ)/ cond. Magnar Mangersnes Simax PSC 1209 76' 35"

Save around 22% with
the retailers listed alongside


This is an important Op. 100, a humbling example of our ignorance of composers from other lands.

Kjell Mørk Karlsen (b. 1947) determined to become a musician after hearing the Matthew Passion when he was 11. He chose the St John Gospel as more suitable for chamber-musical treatment, 'fantastically concentrated, a towering drama etched with the simplest materials'. The narration is shared between choir and tenor Evangelist. Peter and Pilate are sung by tenor and baritone respectively, Jesus himself by three singers, alto and two basses.

The instrumental support is by two oboes, two cellos and organ, that is all. The organ is used sparingly, but to telling effect. The idiom is redolent of chant, chorales and folk-tunes absorbed in contemporary harmonic language, polyphonic and singable, with tight harmonies and a dissonant register. Stravinsky's Mass comes to mind. The original notes for the 1992 premiere describe it as 'a work that embodies great contrasts - - bare, ascetic resonances evoked by the little instrumental ensemble an effective antipode to the dramatic swell of organ and choir'. It plays in a single span, a long choral movement interrupted by solo commentaries and chamber-musical meditations, brilliantly paced to convey an explosive atmosphere, enervation contrasting with a sense of catastrophe. The most extended section is the final 11 minute qui passus est and Amen, which culminates in a shriek of protest.

The Norwegian performance is inspiring and the 1997 recording in Bergen's Biskovan Church captures superbly its intensity. The booklet names every participant and has an interesting, informative commentary by Olav Aune under the title A passion for the half-hearted. A timely release during this special Bach year. I hope that Karlsen's St John Passion will be taken up in UK.


Peter Grahame Woolf




Peter Grahame Woolf

Reviews from previous months

Reviews carry sales links but you can also purchase from:

Return to Index