> Vagn Holmboe - Requiem for Nietzsche [JP]: Classical CD Reviews- Oct 2002 MusicWeb(UK)

MusicWeb International One of the most grown-up review sites around 2024
60,000 reviews
... and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here Acte Prealable Polish CDs

Presto Music CD retailer
Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             

Vagn HOLMBOE (1909-96)
Requiem for Nietzsche (1964)
Helge Rønning (tenor)
Johan Reuter (baritone)
Danish National Choir
Danish National SO/Michael Schønwandt
rec 29-31 Aug 2001, DR Concert Hall DDD
DACAPO 8.224207 [51.44]


Crotchet   AmazonUK   AmazonUS

After Carl Nielsen, Vagn Holmboe is Denmark’s best known composer, having written a very large body of works (almost 400) and concentrating on orchestral, chamber and choral music.

I first came across Holmboe in the late seventies, in a Radio Three series of "Symphonies of the North". My first purchase was the Symphony No.8 on a Turnabout LP with Jerzy Semkow conducting the Royal Danish Orchestra. This was immediately striking and interesting music, and I have acquired many more of Holmboe’s works as they have gradually become more available (the series on BIS is a good example).

This disc is the first of Holmboe’s choral works which I have encountered, and I have been extremely impressed with it.

Dacapo has been releasing other works by the composer, not generally available on other labels, a recent example of which is a pair of discs of the Preludes for Orchestra, both of which have been very well received. With a total of 400 to go for, there is no excuse for extensive duplication, and the current release is to be accepted with rejoicing.

His Requiem for Nietzsche was written in 1964 over a two year period as a direct result of working with a Danish poet (Bjornvig) on a choral cantata for the University of Aarhus in 1959. The text for this had been written by Bjornvig, and during the production, the two men realised that they had much in common, attitudes, outlooks, sense of humour etc. Bjornvig had at this time also written a series of 11 sonnets based upon the life of the German philosopher Nietzsche. These sonnets conjure up a representation of the philosopher’s life, not a blow by blow of what and when he did it, but a representation of his outwardly appreciated feelings and reactions to circumstances.

Holmboe set his Requiem to the texts of the Sonnets and the outcome is a superb choral work, which deserves a wide circulation among music lovers. When we have so much duplication of the standard classics, plus issues of incomprehensible bang crash and shimmer, it makes a refreshing change to welcome a work like this.

It is set in five main sections and is in some ways the most advanced work so far that has been released. Most of Holmboe’s output has been clearly tonal, and this work uses examples of more modern techniques such as whispering, speaking and shouting, all used to great effect. It does not however, leave the tonal territory behind, and so the fusion of the different techniques is used to the effect of the music, rather than for its own sake.

The soloists are first rate, and although I do not understand Danish, I am sure that by using home trained singers, the language is much better served than perhaps by using more international artists. There is no need to qualify the playing of the Danish National Symphony Orchestra which is now provides a background as good as one might be able to expect, ably supported by their superb chorus. The whole is controlled extremely successfully by Michael Schønwandt who has been making a very high reputation for himself over the past five or so years in both this type of repertoire as well as the mainstream catalogue.

John Phillips

Return to Index

Error processing SSI file