> HUGH-JONES Songs [CSS]: Classical CD Reviews- Nov 2002 MusicWeb(UK)

One of the most grown-up review sites around
One of the most grown-up review sites around

Search MusicWeb Here


International mailing

Up to 40% off

  Founder: Len Mullenger

cover scan unavailable
'Poesie et Musique au feminin'
Songs by Elaine HUGH-JONES, and others
Velma Cuyer (soprano)
Martine Jacques (piano)
Rec. DDD
GALLO CD 1070 [65.00?]

'...overflowing of dreams into real life...' (Gérard de Nerval)

The raison d'être of this unusual disc is implied in the title: the feminine in poetry and music - celebrating particularly the work of the Swiss poet and painter Marguerite Burnat-Provins (1872- 1952) - the music (with the exception of that of Elaine Hugh-Jones) by her European contemporaries.

The principal interest for listeners will however be in the cycle of eight de la Mare settings by the London-born pianist and composer Elaine Hugh-Jones (b.1927).

There are however further implications in the title of the CD - the disc is dedicated to Elaine Hugh Jones by the artistes who have, for a number of years, specialised in performing less familiar work by women composers -although this recital is shared (since settings of the poet Burnat-Provins) by such distinguished names as Jacques Dalcroze, Ladmirault, as well as Alma Mahler-Schindler.

This may seem a somewhat diverse company, yet there is an imaginative thematic thread running throughout that derives undoubtedly from a Gallic sensitivity that has something of the symbolist spirit. This ranges from the unseen presences in de la Mare - for instance the mysterious lines from "Echo":

Eyes in the green, in the shade
In the motionless brake,
Voices that said what I said,
For mockery's sake.

to the 'Voiles de mortes/cherchant une forme perdue' of Burnat-Provins and Hartleben's "susser traum"

Elaine Hugh-Jones studied with Lennox Berkeley and also shares something of that French element in her own ancestry with the Huguenot in de la Mare. The first song 'Winter' with its 'rayless sun' evokes that half-real world of twilight - and in this, as in her setting of the ubiquitous 'Silver', one is conscious of Debussy: while there is fantasy in the sinister witchery of 'The Ride by Nights', and in 'The Witch Hare' (does not legend loom large here?) the unseen presences in de la Mare's verse are by contrast pale shades - 'ghosts linger in the darkening air' - less real than the animal presences that seem to hold watch. This is truly a magical cycle.

As in the de la Mare, 'one world trembling on the brink of another' ( * ) colours the other songs and for a music lover these provide a rich added bonus, full of a kind of decadent sensual beauty. There are enchanting lyrical moments in the music of the Breton, Ladmirault - the rhapsodic Ferrari (whose ecstatic climax 'tombe, tombe ma vie aux mains de mon amour' is ravishing) and the folk-like Dalcroze (recalling the nursery world of Inghelbrecht). Carl Ehrenberg's German origins at 'exprimer notre amour' are quite transfigured by the encompassing Gallic ambience.

There. are also five superb lieder by Alma Mahler, whose legendary love affairs have attracted more attention than her music - when she married Mahler he obliged her to give up writing her music to give more attention to her husband - yet the beauty of these lieder cry out for a fuller survey of her few songs (reputedly just over one hundred written, though only a very few survive).

This is a strangely beautiful and compelling recording. I would recommend it, not only for the exquisite settings of the de la Mare, nor even solely for the rich experience of the little known music of Alma Mahler - but even just for the sheer delight in music making of a quality all too rare and for the lovely artistry in the sleeve, with its Pandora, engarlanded in greenery as lush as the music on this disc.

Colin Scott-Sutherland


(*) H.C. Duffin 'Walter de la Mare' Sidgwick & Jackson 1949. Theresa Whistler, in her 'Imagination of the Heart', also wrote 'children feel this world primarily as a projection of another'. Duckworth 1993.


Available in UK from Oakstone Classics (Music Shop) Reindeer Court, Worcester Phone: ( 01905 619629
Disques VDE-Gallo Ale 31
CH-1000 Lausanne 9

Return to Index

Untitled Document

Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.