> GIORDANO Andrea Chenier Tebaldi/Basile 8573874862 [CH]: Classical Reviews- May2002 MusicWeb(UK)






Aureole etc.




Golden Age singers

Nimbus on-line




If it’s the Czech works you’re after, do not hesitate

  Founder: Len Mullenger
Classical Editor: Rob Barnett

Umberto GIORDANO (1867-1948)
Andrea Chénier

Renata Tebaldi (Maddalena), José Soler (Andrea Chénier), Ugo Savarese (Gérard), Ines Marietti (Bersi), Irma Colasanti (Contessa, Madelon), Giuliano Ferrein (Tinville, Roucher), Armando Benzi (Un incredibile)
Coro Cetra, Orchestra Sinfonica di Torino della RAI/Arturo Basile
Recorded 25th May-2nd June 1953, Turin
WARNER FONIT 8573 87486-2 [2 CDs: 54’33"+55’39"] Superbudget

BUY NOW 

AmazonUK   AmazonUS

All very strange. Not long ago I was commenting on a 1952 Cetra set of Guglielmo Tell where the strident sound characteristic of old Cetra LPs had been transferred unadulterated. Somebody’s obviously taken a lot of trouble over this one. The bass is a little light but the upper strings are brilliant without assuming a harsh glare, Giordano’s often busy textures are remarkably analytical and the heavier passages are surprisingly comfortable. Furthermore, the voices are not only firm and clear (perhaps this at least could have been taken for granted) but they mix in with the orchestra most realistically. Obviously a modern recording will give you more detail, spread etc., but for a 1953 recording this is about as good as they come.

Having praised the good work done here, I wish I could tell you that the booklet was a mine of useful information, but it’s not. We get a very brief presentation of the opera in Italian and English, and the libretto in Italian. The booklet actually looks quite substantial, but this is because, for every line that is sung, the librettist, Luigi Illica, adds three or four lines of comment. We do get photographs of Giordano, Illica, Tebaldi and Soler, but considering that this sort of set is most likely to be bought by opera buffs, surely what we really want is information about the singers whose names (with one obvious exception) have rather receded into the mists of time. Hunting around in Internet I can tell you that José Soler was born in 1904 and died in 1999, but that is all. His voice has, in certain notes, an attractive freshness and he holds the high, strenuous lines without apparent difficulty. However, in the middle range his quality is discontinuous and the lower notes are weak. Furthermore, his phrasing is elementary and there’s little characterisation. His most famous aria, "Come un bel dì di maggio", pales before any number of favourite versions and the final scene with Tebaldi seems not so much a duet as a singing lesson, the great lady showing him how it has to go.

Ugo Savarese (1912-1997) left slightly more mark. Many readers will know that he was the Germont on the Callas/Cetra set of La Traviata, and this may not stand in his favour much since that was a dreadful set from everybody except Callas. Here he is perhaps more in his element and makes a good impression in his first scenes. When his big Scarpia-like scene arrives, though, he goes in for some excessive barking (as some Scarpias do) in an attempt to sound suitably malevolent. I also have the idea that he is trying to compensate for a voice that is not especially large, since he is more easily swamped by the orchestra than the others. Still, it is an acceptable souvenir of a singer who did useful work.

"Andrea Chénier" is an opera which is unusually rich in smaller parts that all have something important to do. The general level of the comprimari here is good; some voices are more attractive than others but everybody is well aware of what he has to do - as you would expect of Italians in an Italian opera that was still a solid repertory piece at the time (it doesn’t come up so often today).

As you will have imagined, all this is just clearing the decks before saying that the real reason for bringing this set back into circulation is Renata Tebaldi. Her career was already nine years old in 1953 and in the end she chalked up 88 performances of this role in the theatre. She also recorded it again in 1957 for Decca. Giordano doesn’t give her anything very interesting to do in the first part of the opera (the aria, if you call it that, "Eravate possente" is musically undistinguished) and she is rather impatient with what she has, but she comes fully into her own later on. If you compare her in "La mamma morta" with Callas, for once comparisons all go one way. Perhaps Tebaldi and Basile had the advantage that they were performing in the context of the entire opera while Callas and Serafin were recording a disc of arias. Be that as it may there are many lines – compare them in "E Bersi, buona e pura, di sua bellezza ha fatto un mercato, un contratto per me!" – when Tebaldi really gets into the character while Callas just provides generalised expressiveness. Tebaldi and Basile build the later stages of the aria more patiently, fuelling its fires with a mystic glow where Callas fires her guns straight off (just how much did she care for the piece, I wonder?), and providing plenty of vocal thrills as the climax is reached.

The other big plus of the set is the conducting of Arturo Basile. I admired his Tosca (Warner Fonit 8573 87479-2) and here, too, he captures ideally the ebb and flow which gives life to this kind of operatic writing. Hear him on his own in the charming chorus "O pastorelle addio!" He knows just how to caress the music without letting it sag.

So, get this for a fine, sometimes great, performance by Tebaldi, splendidly conducted. The trouble is, in many ways this is the tenor’s opera (he has more big scenes than the soprano) and, given the inadequate tenor, buying this recording might end up a very expensive way of buying "La mamma morta". The 1957 Decca doesn’t appear to be available but, with a line-up of Tebaldi, Cossotto, Del Monaco, Corena and Bastianini conducted by Gavazzeni, it sounds as if it should be. The sets by Caballé/Pavarotti/Nucci/ Chailly (Decca) and Scotto/Domingo/Milnes/ Levine (RCA), if available, are the obvious modern contenders.

Christopher Howell


Return to Index

Untitled Document


Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.