> Percy Turnbull - The Songs and Part Songs [CSS]: Classical Reviews- May2002 MusicWeb(UK)

One of the most grown-up review sites around

54,416 reviews
and more.. and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here



International mailing

Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             

Percy TURNBULL (1902-1976)
The Songs and Part Songs

Nancy Argenta (soprano)
Roderick Williams (Baritone) Robin Bowman (piano)
The Joyful Company of Singers - Director Peter Broadbent
SOMM CD 020 [63.00?]


AmazonUK   AmazonUS

Percy Turnbull was born in 1902 in Newcastle, training as a chorister in the Cathedral church there and following an arts education in the Armstrong College of Art, the fruits of which can be gauged from the quality of the fine watercolour landscape on the sleeve of this particular CD. He became friendly with the influential W. Gillies Whittaker and in 1922 gained a scholarship to the Royal College to study music.

This slight information is gleaned from the accompanying booklet, since beyond that I know nothing, other than a modest Pasticcio for piano, of what soon appears to be a shamefully neglected composer. Having now come across this disc of his songs, all early works from his twenties, I must ask why it is that songsters such as Haydn Wood and Montague Phillips et al are popular when someone like the Percy Turnbull of these songs, who died in 1976, languishes in the dark? His melodies are equally attractive - I'd even say 'catchy'?

Listening to the very first track of this disc I might easily be tempted to pigeonhole his music amongst the ranks of the art-songsters of the early 20th Century, whose work, delightfully unpretentious, was enjoyed in the family circle in evenings around the piano. I might.

'Chloris in the Snow' is a beautiful little song recalling Somervell and Parry - even Sullivan - as do also his settings of 'My bed is a Boat' and 'The Moon'. But then I realised that, listening, I was concentrating on the melody and only subconsciously registering what the piano was doing. listening further to 'To Julia', 'When Daffodils begin to peer' and 'The Cavalier', I began to appreciate the artistry of these songs and the fact that their immediate melodic appeal is cleverly enhanced by the craftsmanship of the settings. Listen to the treatment, in the first song, of the phrase 'for grief is thawed into a dew' - and in 'To Julia' to the coquettish figuration, which lifts this little vignette into a character portrait of rare individuality. These songs are full of such felicities. Dark moments are few ('To God' is an exception) although there is a Beethovenian grandeur in his Hardy (‘The Reminder') and this, and the Schumannesque 'Guess, Guess' show the fruit of his classical piano tuition under Oppenheimer. With each song the lineage becomes more and more apparent without ever detracting from their individuality. In his 'Cavalier' (Masefield) it is no surprise to learn that at the RCM he studied with John Ireland, and with Vaughan Williams

The melody lines, essentially simple, nevertheless take some lovely turns and if the tune of 'If Doughty Deeds' could easily have been written in the time of Sullivan the piano part is pure Turnbull. The composer is well served by each of the soloists and by the fine, sensitive playing of the pianist Robin Bowman.

The recording, which also includes seven partsongs sung by the appropriately named Joyful Company of Singers under Peter Broadbent, is sponsored by the Turnbull Memorial Trust - and it is to be hoped that a further exploration of Turnbull's work can be facilitated. I for one would be most interested in his chamber music.

Colin Scott-Sutherland

Return to Index

Untitled Document

Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.