Other Links
Editorial Board
- Editor - Bill Kenny
Founder - Len Mullenger
Google Site Search
              SEEN 
              AND HEARD  INTERNATIONAL OPERA  REVIEW
               
                          
                          
                          Munich 
                          Opera Festival 2008 (6):  W.Rihm,  Das 
                          Gehege and R.Strauss,  Salome. 
                          
                          Bayerische Staatsorchester. Conductor. Kent Nagano. 
                          Nationaltheater Munich. 26.7.2008 (JMI)
                          
                          Production Bayerische Staatsoper.
            Director: 
            William Friedkin
            Sets. Hans Schavernoch.
            Costumes: Petra Reinhardt.
            Lighting: Mark Jonathan.
            
            Casts:
            
            Das Gehege.
            The Woman: Gabriele Schnaut 
            The Eagle 
            (Dancer): Steven Barrett.
            
            
            
            Salome:
            
            Salome: 
            Angela Denoke
            Jochanaan: Alan Held.
            Herod: Wolgang Schmidt.
            Herodias: Iris Vermillion.
            Narraboth: Wookyung Kim.
            Herodias's Page: Daniela Sindram.
            
            
            On some occasions (too many perhaps) one leaves the opera more or 
            less disappointed, on some others one leaves satisfied and for a  
            very few, one leaves with the feeling of having attended an 
            exceptional performance.  All opera lovers have memories of 
            performances that have impressed them for special reasons and while 
            they may not be many, some performances are truly unforgettable. 
            This Munich Salome in Munich is one of them. With a 
            spectacular production,  thrilling musical interpretation and 
            an outstanding  cast  (especially the protagonist in Salome) 
            this performance was extraordinary at all levels. I left the opera 
            house thinking that I had been lucky to be there.
            
            Munich's double bill added  Wofgang Rihm’s Das Gehege as 
            kind of prologue to Salome. Kent Nagano himself commission 
            the piece from Rihm, who composed it around a work by the German 
            writer Botho  Strauss. It is full  of German symbolism and  not 
            for nothing  do we find that  the action takes place in 
            Berlin Zoo on the night of the fall of the Wall. A woman visits  
            an eagle's cage (doubtless a clear enough symbol)  frees the 
            eagle and finally kills it. There are clear  parallels between 
            this plot and Salome, particularly at the end.
            
            It is not easy for any contemporary composer to have an opera 
            performed and it is  more difficult still to get new work  
            accepted by the public but Wolfgang Rihm achieves that. This music 
            is much  easier than Rihm’s Jakob Lenz or even Schoenberg's 
            Erwartung which accompanied Salome in Bilbao recently. 
            Das Gehege is a very interesting work, magnificently 
            orchestrated.
            
            The production of this double bill is a work by the  American film 
            director William Friedkin and is  truly spectacular. Hans 
            Schavernoch, one of greatest designers for the stage, provides a 
            series of mobile U-shaped white panels, which frequently change 
            position, offering different stage sets, from an arcade corridor, to 
            a large room in Herod's palace, passing through a spectacular cavern 
            or prison with an enormous truncated wing that comes up from below 
            the stage. All these movements  take place with enormous precision. 
            Costumes are very effective too  and there is more than 
            remarkable lighting. William Friedkin also uses the panels in Das 
            Gehege, adding a human figure (a dancer) as the eagle, who will 
            reappear in Salome as a kind of  Angel of Death, who 
            offers the veils to Salome, takes the ring from Herod's hand and 
            finally kills Jochanaam. Friedkin presents a young and capricious 
            Salome, fully aware of  her erotic powers.  This Princess could 
            not be more credible and  ss I said already, it is one the most 
            spectacular productions I have seen lately, full of good taste and 
            with outstanding interpretations from the singers, particularly 
            Angela Denoke.
            
            Kent Nagano has had  the hard task of replacing Zubin Mehta at 
            Munich for the last two years and I have had the feeling more than 
            once that he does not have the wholehearted approval from the 
            audience, certainly until now.  Nevertheless, in Salome 
            he delivered an outstanding performance, one of the best possible 
            today anywhere. His reading was full of strength and inspiration and 
            he drew a miraculous performance from his great orchestra.  At last,  
            Kent Nagano has proved that he is worthy of his position in Munich 
            and has one his public round.
            
            Angela Denoke was Salome from the moment she came on stage. 
            She lived the character with an extraordinary intensity, putting all 
            her physical resources and expressiveness to its service. She moved 
            on the stage like a cat, becoming the focus of attention for  
            everybody present. She performed the Dance with remarkable agility, 
            worthy of a trained dancer, with the support of the added character 
            of Angel of Death.  She is not too dramatic or too powerful 
            soprano, but it is difficult for anyone to act and sing Salome in 
            such a convincing way. When someone delivers so much intensity and 
            emotion, the details become superfluous. 
            
            In Das Gehege the only singing character is a Woman who has 
            no name as in Erwartung, although in Botho Strauss's play she 
            is identified as Anita von Scharstof, the daughter of an official 
            assassinated for plotting against the Nazis.  Her interpreter 
            was Gabriele Schnaut -  as if she had not sung enough the  
            night before in Elektra. Her interpretation was very 
            convincing though her voice was  much more difficult to control than 
            the previous day, which surely must have been due to accumulated 
            fatigue
            
            American baritone Alan Held was a sonorous and powerful Jochanaan 
            whose interpretation was more full of strength than nuance, with a 
            certain lack of visionary sense.  Wolfgang Schmidt (Herod) has 
            gone from  a dramatic tenor, criticized by all, when he sang the 
            great heroic roles, to become a very good character tenor. For  
            this type of role a voice of great beauty is not required  (his 
            never was) but a convincing portrayal of the character is 
            necessary and Schmidt does  that wonderfully. Iris Vermillion 
            as Herodías, also acted well, again with a powerful but not too 
            beautiful voice. Korean Wookyung Kim was a splendid Narraboth. This 
            tenor has a gorgeous voice, very well projected and  he is also 
            a  remarkable actor, although his appearance may not be that of 
            the romantic hero. He is worthy  consideration for   
            the main lyric repertoire to my mind, although some stage directors 
            would probably  not agree.
            
            The rest of secondary roles were very well performed as usual and 
            there was not a single empty seat to be seen. This was a huge, 
            spectacular triumph for Angela Denoke, who was forced into countless 
            solo  curtain calls. There were triumphant receptions too for 
            Kent Nagano, Wolfgang Schmidt, for Wookyung Kim and for Gabriele 
            Schnaut in Das Gehege. 
            
            Neither glamour, nor mystique really matter in opera. What actually  
            counts is simply  quality which is  what Munich 
            consistently offers.
            
            José M Irurzun
                          
Back to Top Cumulative Index Page
