MusicWeb International's Worldwide Concert and Opera Reviews

 Clicking Google advertisements helps keep MusicWeb subscription-free.

Other Links

Editorial Board

  • Editor - Bill Kenny
  • London Editor-Melanie Eskenazi
  • Founder - Len Mullenger

Google Site Search


Internet MusicWeb


Bull Horn

Price Comparison Web Site



Garsington Opera (2): Vivaldi, L’incoronazione di Dario.  Soloists, Garsington Opera Orchestra, Laurence Cummings (conductor) Garsington Manor, Garsington, Oxfordshire, England. 25. 6.2008 (AO)

Paul Nilon : Dario
Renata Pokupič : Statira
Wendy Dawn Thompson : Argene
Russell Smythe : Niceno
Sophie Bevan : Alinda
Nicolas Watts : Oronte
Katherine Manley : Arpago
Antonia Sotgiu : Flora

David Freeman : director
Dan Potra : designer

Dario (Paul Nilon) and Niceno (Russell Smythe)

Garsington Manor overlooks the Oxfordshire countryside.  Architects call this “borrowed landscape” where vistas extend beyond a property, into the distance.  Garsington Opera productions follow the same principle.  The stage is literally built on the terrace that connects the house to the flower gardens. The performance space is open on one side. Sometimes rain and wind intrude on a performance – as do birds – but that is part of the pleasure.  This is opera which blends theatre and reality, art and nature, and gives Garsington its special charm. This charm is now tinged with melancholy, for productions will only be held here until 2011. Garsington Opera needs a new home.  Whatever happens, though, it has developed a distinctive character which will adapt well to new challenges.  Its founder, the late Leonard Ingrams, knew that chamber operas and rarities are heard to advantage in intimate settings like these.  One of the glories of the English summer is “country house opera”, and Garsington is its embodiment.

Leonard Ingrams also understood the value of extending repertoire, so he would have been delighted that this year, Garsington has brought Vivaldi’s L’incoronazione di Dario to Britain for the first time.  Vivaldi has benefited from the upsurge of interest in the baroque, and his music is still being unearthed.  There was a big demand for music theatre in Vivaldi’s time, and he may have written as many as 100 operas to satisfy the market.  L’incoronazione di Dario was first performed as part of the Venetian Carnival in 1717.  It’s an energetic romp, set in ancient Persia, or rather what early 18th century Venetians took for Persia.  This gives an exotic frisson to what is basically standard mistaken identity farce.  Whoever marries the princess Statira will inherit the empire, so she has three suitors, Dario, Oronte and Arpago.  Each is early defined so the Carnival audience can tell them apart. Dario is the straight man, and hero, while Arpago, the warrior general, would probably have been sung by a castrato or countertenor.  Dario uses Argene, Statira’s sister, to convince Statira to marry him, but she falls in love with him, so she plots to kill her sister and grab Dario and the throne.  Of course, there’s a sub plot involving servants : Statira’s tutor Niceno is secretly in love with her too, and the maid, Flora is pivotal to the action.  It’s pretty much standard fare, the main twists being that all is not righted at the end. Argene and Niceno aren’t saved by some bizarre dramatic device, they are just “disappeared”. This isn’t the carefully crafted harmony of Così fan tutte, though I suspect that it isn’t deliberately dark, but rather unpolished, perhaps because Vivaldi wrote almost 100 of these operas.

Dario (Paul Nilon)  and Statira (Renata Pokupič)

Musically, L’incoronazione di Dario also seems like a mix of standard formulae. In this new critical edition, the arias and recitatives are fairly short and undeveloped. Ideas flash past and aren’t extended as in more sophisticated work. The orchestra has its moments.  When the two theorbos (large and small) play together, they underline the vocal duets, and the violins have many interesting passages, but altogether, there’s no particular structure orchestrally to detract from the lively action. It was a pity, because this orchestra was very good. They are musicians trained to 20th century standards, playing what might have been performed by basic theatre players 300 years ago.  But to their credit, they appreciated that this music works better when it’s played with the vigour and energy it received here.

In many ways, L’incoronazione di Dario is more of a play than an opera, as the vocal demands aren’t great and there aren’t many star turns.  So if the singing was more enthusiastic than polished, it was no problem.  Wendy Dawn Thompson as Argene was excellent : she’s a natural character actress, and the part is piquant.  Paul Nilon as Dario was also impressive. Good performances, too, from Renata Pokupič and the rest of the cast.

Fortunately, if L’incoronazione di Dario doesn’t quite convince as music, this production made it work very well as theatre. The plot is thin and illogical, so the staging turns its weaknesses into virtues. A huge half finished “Persian” head hovers above the stage throughout. It’s the dead King, who interjects during the course of events. At the end, his huge hand is left pointing at the stage.  It’s hilarious. Argene is a princess right out of 50’s America, complete with Elvis Presley 45’s, a gingham crop top and tight jeans. Why, one might ask ? But that’s the whole point. This isn’t supposed to make sense.  Baroque isn’t literal, and this is entertainment, not philosophy.  So when the suitors fight, it’s cod pantomime.  Casting a soprano instead of a countertenor as Arpago the suitor adds yet another irreverent touch. He/she wears the kind of military uniform Michael Jackson might take seriously, for this is the least butch soldier imaginable.  So when he/she sings about being the greatest soldier the kingdom ever had, it’s parody.  This isn’t ancient Persia, whatever the text may pretend. Even Flora, in Persian dress, comes over with wit.

But perhaps the star was the stage itself.  When Statira leaves the palace and heads for the wild, dangerous forests supposedly inhabited by beasts, she can be seen parading through the neat parterres of the flower garden, he wedding dress and train blowing in the breeze.   Dario runs into the garden slashing his sword to create a bouquet for her.  There are lots of real flowers out there, but he brings in an obvious fake, which she swoons over.  He has a “mad scene” in which he slashes one of the two trees on stage in his “rage”, but it’s artificial.  The other tree is real, or looks like it is.  Just as “borrowed landscape” works in the gardens at Garsington, borrowed landscape works in its opera productions.  It expands the stage and participates in the drama, without singing, without music, but very much part of the action.  The actual configuration of terrace and garden may change when Garsington moves, but the imagination and intelligence that it has inspired will live on.

Anne Ozorio

Pictures © Johan Persson

Back to Top                                                    Cumulative Index Page