|  |  |      Editorial 
              Board
 London Editor:
 (London UK)
 Melanie 
              Eskenazi
 
 Regional Editor:
 (UK regions and Worldwide)
 Bill 
              Kenny
 
 Webmaster:
 Bill 
              Kenny
 
 Music Web Webmaster:
 Len 
              Mullenger
    
              
            | MusicWeb is a 
        subscription-free site
 Clicking  Google adverts on our pages helps us  keep it that way
 
 
              
                 
                  
              
          |  
                      
                   Seen 
                    and Heard Concert Review 
                                
                             
                              
  
                                Back 
                              to the Top 
                                  Back to the Index Page 
                                   
                                     
                                       
                                         
                                          
                                          
                                          
                                          Turnage,  About 
                                          Water (world première): 
                                          
                                          
                                          Barb Jungr (vocals), Martin Robertson 
                                          (soprano saxophone), Mark Lockheart 
                                          (tenor saxophone), Gwilym Simcock 
                                          (piano), Gabriella Swallow (cello), 
                                          John Patitucci (double bass), Loré 
                                          Lixenberg (mezzo-soprano), Melanie 
                                          Marshall (mezzo-soprano), Mike Henry 
                                          (tenor), Keel Watson (bass) London 
                                          Sinfonietta, Stefan Asbury 
                                          (conductor),  Queen Elizabeth Hall, 
                                          London, 15.6.2007 (AO)
 
 
 “Ace caff with museum attached” goes 
                                          the notorious ad for the V&A, designed 
                                          to pull in crowds who don’t normally 
                                          like art.    On this glorious summer 
                                          evening the South Bank was packed 
                                          because it’s almost certainly one of 
                                          the most scenic spots in London for 
                                          spending a few hours drinking, 
                                          chatting and chilling out.  In case 
                                          anyone missed the point, raucous noise 
                                          blared from the foyer of the Queen 
                                          Elizabeth Hall, so loud and crudely 
                                          performed that I had to escape 
                                          outside.  The ambience might have 
                                          destroyed more recherché music, like a 
                                          chamber ensemble, but it was 
                                          surprisingly apposite for Mark – 
                                          Anthony  Turnage’s new work About 
                                          Water, specially commissioned for 
                                          the relaunch of the South Bank.  The 
                                          obvious point of reference is water 
                                          but more subtly, as the programme 
                                          notes tell us, “musical ideas 
                                          can….circulate liquidly within an 
                                          environment that confidently embraces 
                                          both jazz and straight classical 
                                          heritages”.
 
 Something here for everyone, then.  
                                          This was music totally accessible to 
                                          people who might otherwise be scared 
                                          off by the tag “new music”, so perhaps 
                                          it’s a good thing that the audience 
                                          was full of new faces, young and 
                                          old.   The jazz elements, too, were 
                                          comfortable and familiar rather than 
                                          jagged edged avant garde.  Indeed, 
                                          there was even a version of Otis 
                                          Redding’s Sitting on the Dock of 
                                          the Bay, adapted loosely but still 
                                          almost easy enough to sing along to.  
                                          Turnage kept its famous refrain 
                                          intact.  It would have been sacrilege 
                                          otherwise! But his point, I think, is 
                                          to show how music  with such strong 
                                          memories can be fun heard in a 
                                          different context.
 
 Fun really did seem to be the keynote 
                                          of this entire work, and why not?  
                                          Turnage has never been stuffy, and his 
                                          collaborator, Barb Jungr, is one of 
                                          the least stuffy people imaginable.  
                                          Her flamboyant liveliness and sense of 
                                          humour are as much a part of the 
                                          creation of this work as the notes 
                                          Turnage has written.  She wrote the 
                                          lyrics for some of the songs, but I 
                                          think her contribution goes deeper.  
                                          She’s a muse, and an icon. So much of 
                                          this music seems to be freely 
                                          improvised, so her personality and 
                                          commitment have a great effect on its 
                                          general direction.  I love that off 
                                          the wall style!
 
 Turnage scores this around a “jazz” 
                                          cell of double bass, piano, singer 
                                          cello, and two saxophonists.   Around 
                                          this basic unit, the Sinfonietta 
                                          provides more conventional “classical” 
                                          support.  There’s also a SATB chorus, 
                                          providing a strange underpinning, part 
                                          gospel choir, part oratorio, part pop 
                                          song backing group.  The “jazz” cell 
                                          is the central unit, around which the 
                                          other elements develop.  In the first 
                                          few songs, there are very long solos 
                                          for double bass, piano, and cello.  
                                          The cello part was rather interesting, 
                                          starting first with electric cello, 
                                          where the sounds of the strings are 
                                          amplified, because there’s no 
                                          resonance from its skeletal body.  The 
                                          instrument is a work of art – a nice  
                                          piece of sculpture to look at, even if 
                                          its sound possibilities are limited.  
                                          Turnage quickly moves back to more 
                                          conventional cello writing, but it’s 
                                          fun while it lasts.  In later parts of 
                                          the work, there’s more quite lovely 
                                          music for cello.  Another more 
                                          intriguing instrument Turnage uses is 
                                          the Armenian duduk, a reed 
                                          instrument that makes wonderful, 
                                          keening wails that sound melancholic, 
                                          poignant and primeval.  Its 
                                          possibilities must be huge, because 
                                          its sound is so distinctive, though 
                                          I’m not sure of its range.
 
 The “jazz” element in this work is 
                                          fairly fundamental, but it’s soft 
                                          jazz, more evocative of Peggy Lee or 
                                          Al Green than anything particularly 
                                          demanding.  There are no Ornette 
                                          Coleman flights of invention here, and 
                                          even the saxophones don’t make an 
                                          appearance until part way through.  
                                          Some of the songs, “instrumentals” to 
                                          use pop terminology, are played by the 
                                          Sinfonietta alone, without the jazz 
                                          cell, allowing them to explore the 
                                          different sensibility.  The interplay 
                                          of genres is quite interesting.  For 
                                          example, flutes and woodwinds take up 
                                          the duduk theme, and the 
                                          “classical” double bass responds to 
                                          the improvised double bass themes.   
                                          Other interesting relationships came 
                                          from the various keyboards and the 
                                          jazz piano.  The harp part was rather 
                                          assertive, the strings plucked to 
                                          sound like a bizarre version of a 
                                          double bass.  True jazz harp! In 
                                          blues, harmonicas are called “harps” 
                                          which raises other intriguing 
                                          possibilities.  Many of the jazz 
                                          standards like Jesus gave me water 
                                          and Take me to the River are 
                                          themselves adaptations of older 
                                          genres, so Turnage is creating a multi 
                                          level tapestry of different styles, 
                                          eras and modes of expression.
 
 Barb Jungr’s singing is most 
                                          congenial, part jazz, part pop, part 
                                          chanteuse.  The chorus members are 
                                          very good singers, clearly classically 
                                          trained, but experienced enough to 
                                          adapt themselves to the different 
                                          context of this work. The audience 
                                          cracked up with delight when the bass 
                                          sang the word “Deep” at the bottom of 
                                          his resonant register.  It would be 
                                          silly to apply art song standards to 
                                          this sort of delivery because that’s 
                                          not at all the point.   What makes 
                                          About Water work is not its 
                                          technical expertise but its general 
                                          good humoured ambience.  It plays with 
                                          genres in a relaxed, uncomplicated 
                                          way, creating an enjoyable, downbeat 
                                          experience.  Nothing here to scare 
                                           anyone new to new music, and enough 
                                          to make them interested, I hope, in 
                                          exploring more, if perhaps not this 
                                          particular work.  Turnage took his 
                                          bows dressed in his trademark tight 
                                          shirt, looking the ultimate in cool.
 
                                          
                                          
                                            
                                          
                                          
                                          Anne Ozorio 
                                          
                                          
                                            
                                          
                                          
                                            |  Seen and Heard, one of the longest established live 
              music review web sites on the Internet, publishes original reviews 
              of recitals, concerts and opera performances from the UK and internationally. 
              We update often, and sometimes daily, to bring you fast reviews, 
              each of which offers a breadth of knowledge and attention to performance 
              detail that is sometimes difficult for readers to find elsewhere.
 Seen and Heard 
              publishes interviews with musicians, musicologists and directors 
              which feature both established artists and lesser known performers. 
              We also feature articles on the classical music industry and we 
              use other arts media to connect between music and culture in its 
              widest terms.  
             Seen and Heard 
              aims to present the best in new criticism from writers with a radical 
              viewpoint and welcomes contributions from all nations. If you would 
              like to find out more email Regional 
              Editor Bill Kenny.   |  | 
         
          
        |  | 
 
              
                 
                  |  Contributors: Marc 
                  Bridle, Martin Anderson, Patrick Burnson, Frank Cadenhead, Colin 
                  Clarke, Paul Conway, Geoff Diggines, Sarah Dunlop, Evan Dickerson 
                  Melanie Eskenazi (London Editor) Robert J Farr, Abigail Frymann, 
                  Göran Forsling,  Simon Hewitt-Jones, Bruce Hodges,Tim Hodgkinson, 
                  Martin Hoyle, Bernard Jacobson, Tristan Jakob-Hoff, Ben Killeen, 
                  Bill Kenny (Regional Editor), Ian Lace, John Leeman, Sue Loder,Jean 
                  Martin, Neil McGowan, Bettina Mara, Robin Mitchell-Boyask, Simon 
                  Morgan, Aline Nassif, Anne Ozorio, Ian Pace, John Phillips, 
                  Jim Pritchard, John Quinn, Peter Quantrill, Alex Russell, Paul 
                  Serotsky, Harvey Steiman, Christopher Thomas, Raymond Walker, John Warnaby, 
                  Hans-Theodor Wolhfahrt, Peter Grahame Woolf (Founder & Emeritus 
                  Editor) |  
 
  Site design: Bill Kenny 
          2004 |