|  |  |      Editorial 
              Board
 London Editor:
 (London UK)
 Melanie 
              Eskenazi
 
 Regional Editor:
 (UK regions and Worldwide)
 Bill 
              Kenny
 
 Webmaster:
 Bill 
              Kenny
 
 Music Web Webmaster:
 Len 
              Mullenger
    
              
            | MusicWeb is a 
        subscription-free site
 Clicking  Google adverts on our pages helps us  keep it that way
 
 
              
                 
                  
              
          |  
                      
                   Seen 
                    and Heard Concert Review 
                                
                             
                              
  
                                Back 
                              to the Top 
                                  Back to the Index Page 
                                   
                                     
                                       
                                         
                                          
                                          
                                          
                                            
                                          
                                          
                                          Hildegard of 
                                          Bingen, Ordo Virtutum: 
                                          
                                          
                                          Vox Animae, Michael Fields (Director) 
                                          Members of the 
                                          
                                          Manchester Chamber Choir,
                                          Bridgewater 
                                          Hall, 
                                          
                                          Manchester. 7.6. 2007 (RJF) 
                                          
                                            
                                          
                                          Hildegard of Bingen was born to noble 
                                          parents in the small village of 
                                          Bemersheim, near Alzey, Rheinhessen, 
                                          Germany in 1098. She was the tenth 
                                          child and as such was dedicated at 
                                          birth to the church as a tithe child, 
                                          in the same way that one tenth of 
                                          income was offered as  a tithe. 
                                          Hildegard  was obviously unusually 
                                          talented  and she attributed her 
                                          skills to visions; later introspection 
                                          indicating to her that she was unique 
                                          in this respect. Aged eight she was 
                                          put into the care of a small community 
                                          of nuns attached to the Benedictine 
                                          monastery of Disibodenberg near Bingen 
                                          south of Mainz. At 38 she founded her 
                                          own convent and became Abbess. Four 
                                          years later a vision, told her to cast 
                                          off her humility, and although this 
                                          was a period when few women wrote, she 
                                          set down her visions and spiritual 
                                          knowledge in three books illustrated 
                                          by ‘illuminations’ of her visions.
 Hildegard ultimately became known as
                                          The Sybil of the Rhine and was 
                                          the most celebrated woman of her age, 
                                          consulted by Bishops, Popes and Kings. 
                                          She was a considerable polymath, 
                                           writing music, plays and  poetry as 
                                          well as more fundamental scripts on 
                                          the nature of life including books on 
                                          natural history and medicine – her 
                                          insights into female reproductive and 
                                          sexual activity were, to say the 
                                          least, unexpected in a celibate 
                                          Abbess. She ascribed all of these 
                                          works to her visions and spiritual 
                                          knowledge.
 
 Spiritual knowledge also illuminated 
                                          her music. Hildegard was a prolific 
                                          composer of spiritual songs, 
                                          introduced to lay audiences (as 
                                          distinct from early music specialists) 
                                          by the recording A feather on the 
                                          breath of God issued on the 
                                          Hyperion label. Performed by Emma 
                                          Kirkby and Gothic Voices this disc 
                                          achieved a Gramophone Award in 1983. 
                                          Since then scholarship has moved on 
                                          considerably as has performing 
                                          practice not least under the influence 
                                          of Michael Fields, Evelyn Tubb and Vox 
                                          Animae who brought Hildegard’s Ordo 
                                          Virtutum to 
                                          
                                          Manchester’s 
                                          Bridgewater Hall.
 
 Ordo Virtutum 
                                          (The Rite of the Virtues) is the 
                                          oldest surviving music drama, and 
                                          perhaps Hildegard's greatest musical 
                                          work. It represents her vision of the 
                                          Soul’s choice between innocence and 
                                          experience, between devotion and 
                                          temptation. The list of virtues 
                                          extends beyond the commonplace to a 
                                          total of seventeen of which the Queen 
                                          is Humility. Evelyn Tubb, with her 
                                          vast experience in this field, allied 
                                          to her extensive vocal range and 
                                          dynamic, sang this pivotal role. Of 
                                          particular note to me was the contrast 
                                          of her ability to sing full out and 
                                          move quickly to sotto voce, yet with 
                                          every word of the text extending out 
                                          into the audience with penetration and 
                                          clarity. As the Soul, Ansy Boothroyd's 
                                          voice had not quite the same quality 
                                          but her acted and sung portrayal was 
                                          nonetheless very moving:  her initial 
                                          response to the temptations of the 
                                          Devil being particularly sensuous when 
                                          Satan slipped off her white habit to 
                                          reveal a black shoulderless dress with 
                                          white hem, a symbol perhaps of Soul's 
                                          innate purity. This contrasted nicely 
                                          with  Ms Boothroyd's  portrayal of 
                                          Soul's later penitence when her 
                                          plaintive singing at the restoring of 
                                          the  white habit was particularly 
                                          expressive and affecting.
 
 Most of the rest of Vox Animae sang 
                                          and acted two of the virtues each. The 
                                          tonal range of the voices was the 
                                          usual female compass and they achieved 
                                          appreciable sonority when singing in 
                                          unison. The quality of the individual 
                                          singing of the various virtues, with 
                                          only the occasional pitching 
                                          assistance from Michael Fields on a 
                                          medieval harp, was of an all-round 
                                          excellent standard in what is clearly 
                                          a very difficult technical discipline. 
                                          The group, appropriately robed, moved 
                                          around the stage and enhanced the 
                                          unfolding drama with appropriate 
                                          gestures and body movements. Audience 
                                          appreciation of the drama, sung in 
                                          clear Latin, was aided by the full 
                                          libretto and translation available in 
                                          the programme.
 
 If Soul was  to be tempted by the 
                                          Devil,  there had to be some  
                                          men around. A mixed male and female 
                                          group from the Manchester Chamber 
                                          Choir sang the Patriarch and Prophets 
                                          with good early music style at the 
                                          start and then sat among the audience. 
                                          John Hanson, a singer in his own 
                                          right, took the spoken part of the 
                                          devil. Looking appropriately debonair 
                                          he would have tempted many a pent up 
                                          virgin! His spoken declamation was 
                                          strong and his intentions clear. He 
                                          takes this part in the DVD recording 
                                          of this work by Vox Animae.
 
 The large Bridgewater Hall was only 
                                          sparsely populated for this concert, 
                                          and this  is probably  a reflection of the general lack 
                                          of awareness of the beauty of both 
                                          this music itself and of Vox Animae's 
                                           combination of  scholarship and vocal 
                                          skill in early music drama. Michael Fields 
                                          gave a most informative 
                                          pre-performance talk whilst Evelyn Tubb appeared on BBC Radio 4’s 
                                          Woman’s Hour on the morning of the 
                                          performance. I hope that the publicity 
                                          for their DVD, and the broadcasts, 
                                          will bring their work (and the 
                                          performance of early music drama in 
                                          general) to a wider audience. 
                                          Certainly the quality of performance 
                                          and the detail of presentation it 
                                          represented deserved a bigger 
                                          audience. I hope too that the warmth 
                                          of the audience reception at the 
                                          Bridgewater Hall served to give 
                                          satisfaction to the performers: they 
                                          deserved all of it.
   
                                          
                                          
                                          Robert J Farr    
                                              |  Seen and Heard, one of the longest established live 
              music review web sites on the Internet, publishes original reviews 
              of recitals, concerts and opera performances from the UK and internationally. 
              We update often, and sometimes daily, to bring you fast reviews, 
              each of which offers a breadth of knowledge and attention to performance 
              detail that is sometimes difficult for readers to find elsewhere.
 Seen and Heard 
              publishes interviews with musicians, musicologists and directors 
              which feature both established artists and lesser known performers. 
              We also feature articles on the classical music industry and we 
              use other arts media to connect between music and culture in its 
              widest terms.  
             Seen and Heard 
              aims to present the best in new criticism from writers with a radical 
              viewpoint and welcomes contributions from all nations. If you would 
              like to find out more email Regional 
              Editor Bill Kenny.   |  | 
         
          
        |  | 
 
              
                 
                  |  Contributors: Marc 
                  Bridle, Martin Anderson, Patrick Burnson, Frank Cadenhead, Colin 
                  Clarke, Paul Conway, Geoff Diggines, Sarah Dunlop, Evan Dickerson 
                  Melanie Eskenazi (London Editor) Robert J Farr, Abigail Frymann, 
                  Göran Forsling,  Simon Hewitt-Jones, Bruce Hodges,Tim Hodgkinson, 
                  Martin Hoyle, Bernard Jacobson, Tristan Jakob-Hoff, Ben Killeen, 
                  Bill Kenny (Regional Editor), Ian Lace, John Leeman, Sue Loder,Jean 
                  Martin, Neil McGowan, Bettina Mara, Robin Mitchell-Boyask, Simon 
                  Morgan, Aline Nassif, Anne Ozorio, Ian Pace, John Phillips, 
                  Jim Pritchard, John Quinn, Peter Quantrill, Alex Russell, Paul 
                  Serotsky, Harvey Steiman, Christopher Thomas, Raymond Walker, John Warnaby, 
                  Hans-Theodor Wolhfahrt, Peter Grahame Woolf (Founder & Emeritus 
                  Editor) |  
 
  Site design: Bill Kenny 
          2004 |