The Sound of Colour: Soloists
/ Almeida Ensemble / Richard Bernas (cond.) Almeida Theatre,
London. 05.07.2006 (ED)
Liszt Der Traurige Mönch: Richard Angas (reciter)
Elégie No.1
Schoenberg Herzgewächse, Op.20: Eileen Hulse
(sop) Pierrot Lunaire, Op.21: Sally Burgess (mezzo)
Mike Ashman (director)
Conor Murphy (designer)
Paul Keogan (lighting designer)
Attending this concert barely a few hours after seeing
the exhibition that it accompanies; ‘Kandinsky:
The Path to Abstraction’ at the Tate Modern
(see
review), I was only too aware of the painter as a
silent protagonist in proceedings here. To all intents
and purposes the major work in the concert was Pierrot
Lunaire, presented in a staging directed by Mike Ashman;however
that is not to demean the individual importance or interest
of the other works.
Liszt’s rarely performed melodrama Der Traurige
Mönch, scored for piano and reciter, established
something of a suspended, eerie atmosphere that was even
more effective because of the intimacy shared by performers
and audience. Richard Angas, dressed in black, appeared
suitably apparition-like against the Almeida’s black
backdrop, to recite Nikolaus Lefanu’s text of ‘The
Woeful Monk.’ This he did with some urgency, although
he brought a flatness of tone to bear in his voice at
times that chilled the air with its words, finding much
that was musical within the poetry in the process. Against
this, Liszt’s piano part weaved and whirled to call
up ghosts of its own – most notably that of Richard
Wagner. Tristan und Isolde was but a thought away
thematically, yet the sparseness with which the piano
commented upon or drew inference from the text lent a
wry humour to the death-laden scene.
Elégie No.1, scored for the unlikely combination
of harp, cello, harmonium and piano, in some ways continued
the mood, though exhibited very different characteristics
in the writing. Cast more fully in the last throes of
Romanticism, the work aired a short mournful cello introduction
before giving way to a decidedly Brahmsian passage. That
these forces to some extent dominated proceedings against
the more ethereal yearnings of both harp and harmonium
served to emphasise that Liszt’s over-riding aim
was the creation and maintenance of musical stasis –
one seemingly without beginning or end, but, as with the
work of many painters, caught in its own abstraction.
Schoenberg’s Herzgewächse, op.20, brought
Kandinsky back into the picture, as it were. The short
score, covering barely four pages of manuscript paper,
was originally published in the Blaue Reiter Almanac in
1912, and was the product of some correspondence between
the two artists. If theoretically it sought to capture
a refraction of colours in sound, in performance the piece
veered almost towards dysfunction with its strangely obsessive
repeated basic tempo. That the performance carried the
intimacy that is needed was positive, that Eileen Hulse
struggled with the fearsomely difficult vocal line took
away from the experience a little. But then, I wondered,
just how performable is the work intended to be if the
soprano is given a high F marked pppp with no time
or leading vocal line to prepare it?
Much more effective in terms of bringing out expressionistic
cross-references between music and colour was Mike Ashman’s
staging of Pierrot Lunaire. Ashman and conductor
Richard Bernas went to great pains in trying to approximate
the atmosphere and effects of Pierrot’s original
stagings, given in pan-German tours by the formidable
singer/actress Albertine Zehme. That Zehme had in her
time studied both Brünnhilde and Kundry at Bayreuth
with Cosima Wagner says much for her vocal abilities and
neatly counters the myth that she sought from Schoenberg
a vehicle from that might have been more suited to the
vocal ‘talents’ of a Florence Foster Jenkins.
For all the work’s internal obsessions with neurosis
and numerology this was a profoundly musical performance,
given a searing intensity by the interpretation of Sally
Burgess. Just as the vocal part darts between speech and
song, resting largely in the hinterland of Sprechstimme,
immediacy of facial expression and acting aided a wider
exploration of the text. That references in costume were
made to Pierrot’s clown-history were enough, but
that they cast the figure (Burgess appeared strangely
androgynous) in a universal light proved all the more
disturbing. True to Zehme’s stipulation the instrumental
forces were obscured from view by a large screen –
a central breach in which allowed for only fleeting communication
between the performers. All the potential difficulties
did not impede Bernas’ judiciously chosen tempi
or the clarity of playing he drew from the small band.
Light, though, served as the unifier in this performance,
in that it picked up on textual elements – representations
of the moon at appropriate moments – or that by
its use an extra layer of meaning might be drawn from
text or music. Schoenberg must have known about Kandinsky’s
short stage-play Der gelbe Klang (The Yellow Sound)
written for the Blaue Reiter Almanac, with its use of
coloured lighting to create atmospheres around the specific
musical notes and textures. Paul Keogan, the lighting
designer, did much the same here with evocative purples,
blood-reds and watery blues of unfathomable depth. By
these tones he brought us to the verge of a gesamtkunstwerk
so absorbing yet intimate of scale as to be almost more
effective than anything created by Wagner in its ability
to change listeners in the course of hearing . More so
than is often the case when given in concert, Pierrot
Lunaire had re-discovered some of its ability to shock.
Evan Dickerson