One of the most grown-up review sites around
One of the most grown-up review sites around

Search MusicWeb Here


International mailing

Up to 40% off

  Founder: Len Mullenger

Arnold (1921-) - Symphony No. 2

The snobbishness of the élitists was, with Malcolm Arnold, not limited to his Second Symphony, but generously extended to his entire output. Fortunately, he is lately gaining some recognition, but for too long his "problem" was that he wrote nice tunes in an age when tunes (except those to facilitate respiration) were well and truly "out". 

Worse, he also wrote music for films - the Establishment was definitely not amused: anyone who writes tunes and film music cannot possibly have any real substance (and yet the St. Trinians “Flash 'arry” soundbite, to cite just one example, is a small stroke of pure genius). What amazes (and amuses) me is that Shostakovich was not similarly condemned. After all, he committed the same crimes. But then, I suppose, it was alright because he was foreign

The symphony was written to a commission from the Bournemouth Winter Gardens Society, completed in 1953, and premièred by its dedicatees, the then Mr. Charles Groves and the then Municipal Orchestra, in May of that year. As an orchestral player himself, Arnold had studied the reactions of both musicians and audiences, and consciously set about crafting music that would be gratifying to play as well as to hear. 

As it happens, the parallel with Shostakovich goes deeper. In both, a carefree surface often conceals a dark and dangerous undercurrent, which can rise to conflict with the superficial jollity, or simply "blow it away". Arnold is something of an "English Shostakovich", as exemplified, I think, by the Second Symphony. This is a symphony suffering psychoses, a distant relation perhaps of the Symphonie Fantastique

The 1st movement (allegretto) sets out with a characteristically genial, mildly cheerful tune which soon begins to suffer disfiguring waves of anxiety, even the odd fit. 

The 2nd movement (vivace) dances happily, but rapidly develops schizoid tendencies with sudden, violent bursts of  anger, and obsessive chattering. 

In a film the 3rd movement (lento) might well have been used to underpin some scene of a post-nuclear holocaust desert, but here the landscape is that of the hopeless mind of a depressive. 

The 4th movement (allegro con brio) is a nightmare, a succession of surreal images that might be comical were they not so fearful. The real shock comes at the end: a colossal, grinding crisis suddenly dissolves into catharsis, a brief, unexpected awakening. So, it was really only a "Dream of a Psycho-Sabbat" after all - phew, what a relief... 

This is a symphony worthy in every respect to be ranked alongside the best. It is full of technical subtlety for the cerebral listener, and yet (no mean feat, this) is not afraid to entertain the public at large. As was said on the way to the Forum, "Something for everyone, a Comedy tonight!", an apt quote for a man who sees music as "a social act of communication among people", had no time for purveyors of ivory tower élitism, and had the courage to stick to his principles while they ruled the roost and committed him to the sidelines. Tonight you have a golden opportunity to rise and shout "Viva, Malcolm Arnold!"

© Paul Serotsky
29, Carr Street, Kamo, Whangarei 0101, Northland, New Zealand


Conditions for use apply. Details here
Copyright in these notes is retained by the author without whose prior written permission they may not be used, reproduced, or kept in any form of data storage system. Permission for use will generally be granted on application, free of charge subject to the conditions that (a) the author is duly credited, and (b) a donation is made to a charity of the author's choice.

Return to: Music on the Web