Summer 2005 Film Music CD Reviews

Film Music Editor: Ian Lace
Managing Editor: Ian Lace
Music Webmaster Len Mullenger

index page/ monthly listings/ Summer/

DVD Review

Wonderful Town (1953): Excerpts from the Musical Comedy in Two Acts  
Music composed by Leonard Bernstein
  Performed by Berlin Philharmoniker and European Voices (Chorus Master: Simon Halsey)
Conducted by Sir Simon Rattle
(rec. live at the Philharmonie,Berlin30-31 December 2002)
Ruth Sherwood/Violet…Kim Criswell
Eileen Sherwood…Audra McDonald
Robert Baker…Thomas Hampson
First Editor/
Frank Lippincott…Brent Barrett
  Available on Euroarts DVD 2052299
Running Time: 76 minutes
Crotchet   Amazon US

Wonderful Town, was based on the play My Sister Eileen, which in turn, was filmed byColumbia, in 1942, under that name, starring Rosalind Russell (Ruth) and Janet Blair (Eileen). It was filmed again in 1955 using the same title, this time with Betty Garrett, Janet Leigh, Jack Lemmon, Bob Fosse and Tommy Rall.Columbiawere too mean to fork out for the winning stage-score and engaged Jule Styne and Leo Robin to write a substitute. It was no match for this Bernstein original.

Leonard Bernstein enthusiasts may recall that, in 1998, EMI issued an audio recording by Simon Rattle of Wonderful Town with the London Voices, the Birmingham Contemporary Music Group and the same four soloists featured on this DVD (EMI 7743 5 56753 2 3). This is a live performance recorded inBerlinas a 2002-03 New Year celebration concert with Rattle and his soloists, choir, orchestra - and even the audience to judge by their enthusiastic participation in the Conga encore - in merry festive mood.  Certainly Rattle is animated throughout, sheer joy reflected in his face.

Wonderful Town opened on Broadway in 1953 and ran for 559 performances. It starred Rosalind Russell as Ruth, and Edith Adams as Eileen. Today, Wonderful Town is largely overshadowed by Bernstein’s other stage works like On the Town and West Side Story which is a pity as this sparkling Rattle performance proves. Its story is about two sisters from Ohio and their wacky adventures in New York’s Greenwich Village. Eileen’s beauty enslaves the men, including half the police force in the very witty ‘My Darlin’ Eileen’ in which they insists she is Irish because they think she "comes from Kilarney." But Sister Ruth just wants to become a successful writer. Bernstein’s exuberant, jazz-based score is big and breezy especially in the colourful celebration of the larger-than-life characters of ‘Christopher Street.’ The score also embraces the conga, swing and rag forms and even the form that characterised the sort of song that spilled from the lips of Roy Rogers or Gene Autry as the sisters Ruth and Eileen sing Ohio and rue abandoning their safe rural backwater for the uncertainties ofNew York.. All the singers are excellent, attacking their characterisations with great enthusiasm and commitment, and relishing the sharp-witted lyrics of Betty Comden and Adolph Green. Audra McDonald as Eileen is sweetly sentimental in ‘A Little Bit in Love’ while the animated, raucous, gravely-voiced Kim Criswell, as Ruth, is wickedly funny in ‘One hundred easy ways to loose a man’. The ever-versatile and impressive Thomas Hampson is Howard Keel-like romantic in ‘It’s Love.’  Brent Barrett is wickedly funny singing as the knuckle-headed Wreck, and commenting that he might be as thick as six planks but he ‘gets through college and ‘passes’ exams, and gets the best jobs because he can ‘Pass the football’.

Three cheers for Lenny and Simon Rattle et al. This is wonderful light entertainment for a summer’s evening. It really is a Wonderful Town. It goes straight to the top of my list of favourite recordings for 2005.

Ian Lace

Not rated.

Return to Index

Reviews from previous months

You can purchase CDs, tickets and musician's accessories and Save around 22% with these retailers: