November 2004 Film Music CD Reviews

Film Music Editor: Gary S. Dalkin
Managing Editor: Ian Lace
Music Webmaster Len Mullenger

index page/ monthly listings / November /

Once Upon A Time…  The Essential Ennio Morricone Film Music Collection
Ennio Morricone
  The City of Prague Philharmonic & Crouch End Festival Chorus
Conducted by Paul Bateman, Nic Raine, Derek Wadsworth, James Fitzpatrick
  Available on Silva Screen SILCD1165
Total running time: 113.03
CD1: 56.26
CD2: 56.37
Crotchet   Amazon UK   Amazon US

once upon a time

Disc 1

  1. Once Upon a Time In the West (Man With the Harmonica)
  2. A Fistful of Dollars
  3. For a Few Dollars More
  4. Days of Heaven
  5. The Five Man Army
  6. Once Upon a Time In The West (Jill's Theme)
  7. The Men From Shiloh
  8. Guns For San Sebastian (Overture)
  9. Two Mules For Sister Sara
  10. My Name Is Nobody
  11. The Good, The Bad and The Ugly (Main Theme)
  12. The Good, The Bad and The Ugly (The Ecstacy of Gold)
  13. Cinema Paradiso
  14. Once Upon a Time In America (Deborah's Theme)

Disc 2

  1. The Untouchables (Main Theme)
  2. The Red Tent
  3. The Sicilian Clan
  4. Exorcist II: The Heretic (Regan's Theme)
  5. Moses The Lawgiver
  6. In The Line of Fire
  7. The Thing
  8. Le Professionnel (Chi Mai)
  9. 1900 (Romanza)
  10. Casualties of War (Elegy for Brown)
  11. Marco Polo
  12. The Mission
  13. Gabriel's Oboe
  14. Ave Maria (Guarini)
  15. On Earth as It Is In Heaven
  16. Epilogue (The Falls)
  17. See also:
    Yo Yo Ma Plays Ennio Morricone

    Once Upon A Time… is the latest addition to Silva Screen's very useful Essential Film Music Collection, and follows volumes devoted to Miklós Rózsa, Jerome Moross, Maurice Jarre and others. Ennio Morricone is one of the most anthologised film composers ever, so compared with the sets cited above this particular release has a lot of competition. As usual the selections are new recordings rather than original soundtracks, and are delivered with the customary rich and lavish Silva Screen sound courtesy of The City of Prague Philharmonic and Crouch End Festival Chorus.

    Morricone has been a massively prolific composer with over 300 film and television scores to his credit. He is best known for two things: his collaborations with director Sergio Leone, from which the current set takes its title, and for his lushly romantic themes for any number of diverse films. Naturally enough Once Upon A Time… concentrates on those aspects of the composer's music, presenting versions of all Morricone's most famous melodies. As such it is the perfect introduction to his music for the non-fanatic who does not insist recordings adhere to the original recording in every last detail. It is also a fine set for the more general Morricone fan who will have the originals of some of this music, but almost certainly far from all. Of course the serious Morricone devotee will already have all the original soundtracks…

    The set is clearly divided in two. The first CD contains music almost entirely from Westerns, mostly of the spaghetti sort, many directed by Leone. The only exception is the theme from Cinema Paradiso, which really does belong on the second CD, a programme of miscellaneous themes, mostly romantic, including a five movement suite from The Mission. The second disc is more successful than the first for the simple reason that Morricone's Western music – especially the Dollars Trilogy (A Fistful of Dollars, For A Few Dollars More, The Good, The Bad and The Ugly) – is so intimately associated not just with its melodies but with the highly original and idiosyncratic orchestrations of the original soundtracks that any new version inevitably sounds "wrong" even to non-purist ears. Which is not to say that the versions of those themes as presented here are "bad" – they are not, being often very spirited and polished – but merely not being the originals proves a major hurdle to overcome. For those who can there is much to enjoy here, particularly the wonderful 'The Harvest' cue from the more conventional Days of Heaven. Generally though, for reworked versions of this music, rather than the originals, one can not currently surpass the utterly superb recent release, Yo Yo Ma Plays Ennio Morricone.

    Conversely, the second CD really is something of a treat. Here are fine versions of many of Morricone's most sublime inventions. From a rousing take on the main theme from The Untouchables onwards the disc rarely puts a foot wrong. The theme from the little seen The Red Tent is a captivating soprano melody in the tradition of the composer's work on Once Upon A Time in the West – and soloist Charlotte Kinder acquits herself with flying colours (as indeed she does on Exorcist II and the version of 'The Ecstasy of Gold' from The Good, The Bad and The Ugly on the first disc). At the other extreme the theme from The Thing retains all the chilling power of the unique original, and 'Chi Mai' recaptures the startling combination of luxurious strings and syndrums of the 1980's hit. In The Line of Fire also comes up trumps with an iconic modern action thriller theme from the top draw.

    Inevitably the album ends with the five part suite from Morricone's most celebrated score of (comparatively) recent times, The Mission. Recorded numerous times, the versions here of the now classic themes are among the best available, distilling the essence of the score into 13 beautiful minutes.

    With two discs for the price of one Silva Screen have another winner with a solid addition to any collection.

    Gary Dalkin

    **** 4

Return to Index

Reviews from previous months

You can purchase CDs, tickets and musician's accessories and Save around 22% with these retailers: