April 2000 Film Music CD Reviews

Film Music Editor: Ian Lace
Music Webmaster Len Mullenger


GILBERT & SULLIVAN (arr. Carl Davis) Topsy-Turvy OST    SONY SK61834 [65:35]

Save around 22% with
the retailers listed at the side



Mike Leigh who is better known for his more earthy screenplays on contemporary mores, now turns his lens on Gilbert and Sullivan, evoking as he says the atmosphere of their world rather than simply documenting their story. His musical collaborator was fellow

G & S enthusiast, Carl Davis who had actually played rehearsal piano for his local G & S Society and arranged a Sullivan ballet for the re-opening of the Savoy Theatre after its terrible 1991 fire.

For the film Davis conducted extracts from the three operas that figure in the action of the film: Princess Ida, The Sorcerer and the ever-popular The Mikado. Leigh explains, to answer potential complaints about favourites being omitted, that numbers were chosen to suit the requirements of the story. Nevertheless, a goodly number of Mikado favourites are included here such as 'A Wand'ring Minstrel I'; 'Three Little Maids from School Are We'; 'A more Human Kind of Mikado' in which the Mikado is anxious "To let the punishment fit the crime"; and, of course Behold, The Lord High Executioner'. Timothy Spall as the Mikado is excellent. Yet he is overshadowed by the gloriously OTT expressive singing of Martin Savage in so many of the comic numbers like 'If You Give Me Your Attention' from Princess Ida in which King Gamma boasts "I've an irritating chuckle, I've a celebrated sneer, I've an entertaining sneer, I've a fascinating leer..." but then wonders why "Yet everybody says I am a disagreeable man! I can't think why!"

Interspersed with the vocal numbers, are a few orchestral interludes that Carl Davis has arranged from Sullivan's music for other shows including The Gondoliers, The Yeoman of the Guard and The Grand Duke. Three Overtures are also included: Princess Ida, The Mikado and The Yeoman of the Guard. In keeping with the general Victorian atmosphere the album also includes a rendering of Sullivan's much lampooned The Lost Chord, with those immortal lyrics - "Seated one day at the organ, I was weary and ill at ease…It might be that Death's bright Angel Will speak in that chord again.. "

Curiously, the album ends in a rather depressing downbeat mode with the slow measured tread of Resolutions from 'The Long day Closes.' Keen film and film music enthusiasts will remember that this was used most movingly in the passing clouds sequence that ended Terence Davies' wonderful film, The Long Day Closes.

The sumptuously illustrated booklet includes biographical notes about Gilbert & Sullivan, a useful timeline charting the dates of all their operas and brief synopses of all three featured operas, plus the words of all the songs featured in this album which will be cherished by G & S fans

Reviewer

Ian Lace


Reviewer

Ian Lace


Reviews from previous months


Reviews carry sales links
but you can also purchase
from:







Return to Index