April 2000 Film Music CD Reviews

Film Music Editor: Ian Lace
Music Webmaster Len Mullenger


Jerry GOLDSMITH The Flim-Flam Man [33.15]; A Girl Named Sooner [31.13] FILM SCORE MONTHLY Vol. No. 9 [64.28]

Save around 22% with
the retailers listed at the side

   


Here is a return to the good old double-feature which some people will tell you just isn't economically viable. Well it happened with Jerry Goldsmith's Capricorn One / Outland, both of which had previously been issued as single LPs, but this disc goes one further by combining two previously never-fully-released-before soundtracks from the composer's back catalogue. As with all Film Score Monthly releases, great care and attention has been lavished in the production, with detailed notes putting everything in context, a decent selection of stills, and most importantly of all, very good sound quality.

The first half of the disc (tracks 1-17) comprises the score to a 1967 comedy staring George C. Scott and Michael Sarrazin. The Film-Flam Man (released in the UK as One Born Every Minute) was a comedy drama about the relationship between an ageing con man and his young protégé. The setting was small-town America, and the film, which was a box-office failure, appears to have been one of several late 60's, early 70's films, from The Skin Game to The Sting, to explore similar territory. It was directed by Irvin Kershner, who apart from The Empire Strikes Back, was one of Hollywood's most consistently disappointing film makers. He would later work with Jerry Goldsmith again on 1974's S*P*Y*S.

The music is in a very folksy, country-blues idiom, with much use made of harmonica and banjo, with often a lightweight, playful feel, set against tracks of more pastoral, whimsical beauty. This is rather more carefree and more lavishly orchestrated, but essentially in a similar vein to Goldsmith's classic A Patch of Blue (1965). The country-fair, slapstick burlesque writing is very evocative of American comedies of the period (It's A Mad, Mad, Mad, Mad World by Ernst Gold comes to mind), and while less attractive on disc than the more romantic writing, is inventively scored and arranged, and full of witty touches.

A lot of work has gone into bringing this music to disc. Fortunately all the master elements survived, allowing a new stereo mix to be created. Originally the orchestra tracks and the 'tack piano' - actually a conventional piano with the tape speeded-up - were recorded separately and edited together for the film. Additionally the scoring calls for harp, guitars, marimba, assorted wooden percussion and triangle. Synchronising the orchestra, banjo and harmonica with the tape of the honky-tonk sounding piano had actually proved too difficult for The Tribute to Jerry Goldsmith CD released in 1993, so that certain parts of the score were omitted from that issue. Here, for the first time, all the music has been assembled, and a fine job producer, mixer and editor Douglass Fake has made of it too. This is a production to be celebrated, with a very clear and well defined sound-stage offering a refined musical canvas.

The second half of the album (tracks 18-33) presents the music from A Girl Named Sooner, a well loved TV Movie from 1975. The music has been mastered from the only source available, first generation mono tapes. There is some harshness, particularly to louder flute passages, but generally the sound is very good, again with lots of detail. Making this a particularly rewarding disc, this second score is another in a similar vein to A Patch of Blue. Here the comedy is absent, leaving a gossamer filigree of Southern wistfulness. Written the year after Papillon, there is something of the character of the more poetic music from that score, while the instrumentation is much the same as on The Flim-Flam Man, the 'tack piano' excepted. Small hints of what was to come in Logan's Run (1976), can also be spotted, though one caveat is that many of the tracks are very short, and even within tracks, the scoring is often quite fragmented.

Melodically accomplished, and above all subtle, with a real sense of musical texture and dynamics, this is an album all Goldsmith fans will want to acquire, but which should particularly be music to the ears of those who feel that today the composer's writing suffers from a surfeit of bombast. I'm not one of them, but I can see the point; the scores here offering film music from the days before composers were forced to compete with every sound-effect being presented in deafening DTS.

Reviewer

Gary S. Dalkin

[This CD is available exclusively from the magazine and website (www.filmscoremonthly.com) for $19.95 plus shipping: Film Score Monthly, 8503 Washington Boulevard, Culver City, CA90232. Phone: 310-253-9595; Fax: 310-253-9588; Lukas@filmscoremonthly.com ]


Reviewer

Gary S. Dalkin


Reviews from previous months


Reviews carry sales links
but you can also purchase
from:







Return to Index