Aureole etc.

Golden Age singers

Nimbus on-line

Faure songs
Charlotte de Rothschild (soprano);

  Founder: Len Mullenger
Classical Editor: Rob Barnett


Franz SCHUBERT (1797-1828)
Quintet in A Major D.667 ‘The Trout’ or ‘Die Forelle’ (1819)
Trio in Eb Major ‘Notturno’ D.897 (1828?)
Ensemble Villa Musica/Leonard Hokanson, conductor.
No date given for recording or filming.
NAXOS DVDI 1026 [50.00]


Crotchet   AmazonUK   AmazonUS

I must say straight away that I expected great things from this DVD. I have been an admirer of the Naxos project for many years now and felt that they have made one of the most significant contributions to recording history. The Trout Quintet is one of my favourite chamber works - having discovered it as a teenager and loved it ever since. Furthermore I believe that Austria has great natural beauty and is saturated with musical history. So it came as a surprise to discover that the DVD is mediocre – at least the visual element. The recording by Ensemble Villa Musica is excellent – I have no complaint here. The bottom line is that I imagined that after watching this on the television, I would be compelled to book a holiday in Austria straightaway and start planning a musical pilgrimage to the wonderful places presented on film. In reality, however, the photography could be summed up as pleasant; it is most certainly not stunning or inspiring. Much of it seems to be of everyday people walking about workaday streets doing errands. A lot of the images could have been filmed in many other European countries. Even the vineyards outside Vienna could have been the fruit farms of Lanarkshire!

Anyway let’s have a few words about the Trout Quintet. It is often useful to remind ourselves about the genesis and content of a very familiar work. The Quintet in A major D.667 was composed in 1819. It has the distinction of being one of the earliest piano quintets to be written. However it is not for the traditional combination. Schubert used Violin, Viola, Cello and Double Bass along with the piano. There is no part for the second Violin. The work was called The Trout or Die Forelle, as is well known, because the 4th movement quotes the Schubert song of the same name. The work is full of sunshine and it is not hard to see why. Schubert wrote this work during one of the very few happy periods in his life. He was on a walking holiday with his friend Johann Michael Vogl in Austria at that time and was exploring the area around Steyr. He stayed at the house of Sylvester Paumgartner for a number of weeks. His host had requested a chamber work that could be given at his residence. Schubert had obliged and had quickly composed the work. In fact he only wrote out the string parts – he played the piano part from memory at its first residential performance. The composer completed the work after his return to Vienna.

The quintet is in five movements as opposed to the traditional four. These are 1.Allegro vivace. 2. Andante. 3. Presto. 4. Andantino and 5. Allegro Giusto. The first movement is the longest and throughout this there is a riot of lovely tunes. The second movement is more reflective. Schubert based the third and last movements on Austrian folk dances. The fourth movement, of course, is a series of six variations on Die Forelle.

The other work on this DVD is the Trio (or Adagio) in Eb major D897 ‘Notturno.’ Schubert had written two considerable works for piano trio: the Bb (D898) and the Eb (D.929), both being masterpieces. In addition to this there were two smaller pieces – the Piano Trio in one movement in Bb D28 and the present 'Notturno'. The title was not originally given by the composer but was appended to the work by the publisher, Diabelli. It is a lovely work that is a joy to listen to. It deserves to be better known.

One point to ponder on this recording: it is strange that the ensemble requires a ‘conductor.’ The names of the individual players are not given.

As I mentioned above, the imagery given to these two works is hardly designed to show off Austria at its best. I can see what the camera operator was trying to do – he was attempting to create a mood picture rather than a publicity film. Yet the film does seem dull. Even the lovely town of Baden does not seem to be presented in the best light. Many of the images concentrate on the architecture of commonplace buildings. I did get a bit excited seeing shots of a quaint narrow gauge steam locomotive and train following the banks of the River Steyr. But perhaps mechanical signals will not appeal to all tastes. To be fair, there are some nice shots of Alpine pasture and running water.

The film appears to be quite old – just look at the clothes the public are wearing – and this contention is borne out by the fact the that the box states it has been ‘re-mastered’.

I do not believe this DVD to be a particularly good fusion of sights and sounds. It needed just a little bit more pizzazz. I really did hope to be phoning the travel agent up to inquire about weekend breaks in Austria. Perhaps I will just go to North Wales instead – they too have lots of narrow gauge trains-and lots of running water.

Great music that is not enhanced by the somewhat pedestrian film. It would not encourage me to book a holiday in Austria.

John France

Gerard Hoffnung CDs

Advertising on

Donate and get a free CD

New Releases

Naxos Classical


Musicweb sells the following labels
Acte Préalable
Cameo Classics
Northern Flowers
Toccata Classics

Follow us on Twitter

Subscribe to our free weekly review listing

Sample: See what you will get

Return to Index

Untitled Document

Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.