Though Cetra used to be considered valuable above all
for Italian operas that were not otherwise available, this set shows
that at least some of its all-Italian (or nearly so) versions of Mozartís
Italian operas deserve a second look. The more so when we no longer
have to endure Cetra sets in strident sound; this is forward and clear
and equal to practically anything from the same date.
The conductor Max Rudolf was born Max Rudolph in Germany
in 1902, began to work in the German Opera House in Prague in 1929,
emigrated to the USA in 1940 and started his association with the Metropolitan
Opera House in New York in 1945, becoming its artistic administrator
from 1950-1958. In that year he moved to the Cincinnati Symphony Orchestra,
where he remained until 1970. There followed three years at the Curtis
Institute and appointments in Dallas and New Jersey. He conducted for
the last time at the age of 90 and died in 1995.
Something of a legend in his adopted country, Rudolf
did not figure much in the major companiesí recording programmes and
his name probably does not mean very much to European listeners. A number
of records made with Cincinnati SO were available on LP in the UK in
the 1970s and failed to make an impression. I suppose you could say
that in the present instance he offers above all clean textures and
a good deal of energy rather than great insights (I certainly thought
this during the overture), but in the opera pit this counts for much.
He sees that the drama unfolds at the right pace and negotiates a labyrinth
of tricky tempo changes in the first act finale without putting a foot
wrong. Many of his tempi are challengingly fast and we should note that,
while the Mozart of many contemporaries who were judged his superior
in their day (Böhm for instance) now sounds heavy, Rudolfís does
Most lovers of this opera will have Taddeiís performance
of Leporello in the famous Giulini set made a few years after this.
They will surely welcome the chance to put his Don alongside it. This
is a Don Giovanni who maintains the veneer of a gentleman and is all
the more dangerous for it. His half-voice in the serenade is a remarkable
piece of vocal control. By his side is Italo Tajo, a skilled practitioner
of small parts on disc over a period of many years. His vocal acting
is excellent and in his scenes with Don Giovanni his rather overbearing,
truculent Leporello sometimes seems to be getting the upper hand. In
their recitatives they really strike sparks off each other; thereís
no match for Italians doing this sort of thing in their own languages.
His actual voice is revealed, especially in the company of Taddeiís
sharply focused vocal production, to be a little cavernous and woolly,
but itís a splendid performance even so.
Cesare Valletti (1921-2000) later sang Don Ottavio
both at the Met and at Salzburg. His way with the part is more openly
passionate than, say, Anton Dermotaís gently besotted lover; itís a
stronger type of voice than we would be likely to use for Mozart today.
On the other hand, any attempt to make Don Ottavio a little less one-sided
as a character than usual is all to the good.
In my recent review of Carla Gavazziís Adriana Lecouvreur
I told what I know about her, and refer readers there. Even taking into
account Taddei, she could be a principal reason for getting the set.
She has character; from the moment she enters her words have
a life that holds the attention. However, you are also warned that this
is a way of singing Mozart to which we are not used today. She unhesitatingly
uses chest tones on lower notes, her vowels are often bitingly brilliant
and she at times applies a rapid vibrato. She throws herself passionately
into the coloratura passages and, while I donít suggest the notes are
not there, itís a far cry from the "string of pearls" concept
of Mozartian passage-work that is more common. For her, also the coloratura
has to mean something. Unorthodox Mozart, but done with such
conviction to make you wonder if her way is not the right one after
all. Though Gavazziís career was curtailed and her records were few,
the evidence is that she was an artist of some importance.
Maria Curtis Verna is the one non-Italian in the cast,
though since she was established in Italy at the time of the recording
she certainly sounds idiomatic enough. Born Mary Curtis, she acquired
an extra Italian surname and Italianised her first name, and was much
admired in Italy for a few years (at about this time she also recorded
Aida, with Franco Corelli, and Un Ballo in Maschera, with
Tagliavini and Valdengo, both for Cetra). After this she returned to
the USA, varied her name again to Mary Curtis-Verna, and appeared regularly
at the Met. I can trace no recordings from her later period. She also
became active as a teacher.
Itís a rich, almost mezzo-like voice. Indeed, certain
signs of strain in the upper register suggest she may actually be a
pushed-up mezzo more than a real soprano, but I must say the coloratura
in Non mi dir is safely negotiated and she is impressive in Or
sai chi líonore. Her style is not always clean, without the compensation
of Gavazziís strong personality, and her vocal production perhaps relies
on volume more than perfect focus. She is the weakest link in a strong
cast, but is by no means to be dismissed.
Elda Ribettiís main claim to fame is that she sang
Oscar in the 1943 Ballo in Maschera with Gigli and Serafin. She
has a soubrettish voice, but with more body than usual for this sort
of part and gives a strong performance. I can find no information about
Vito Susco but this is an acceptable Masetto, and once again he and
Ribetti really know how to make the recitatives fly off the page.
Antonio Zerbini (1924-1987) offers a good Commendatore
without the last ounce of massive authority needed to drive the climatic
It hardly need be stated at this stage that the above
information does not come from the booklet which, as is the way
with these Cetra reissues, offers an introductory note, in Italian and
English, and the libretto in Italian. Regarding the performers, the
merits of Taddei are extolled, which most of us know anyway, but nothing
is offered on the more elusive ones. We do get photos of all of them,
With so many important versions of Don Giovanni
in the catalogue I suppose this is not exactly a first choice, but
it adds up to more than the sum of its considerable parts and if it
did happen to be the only one on your shelf youíd get all the right
ideas about the opera. Opera buffs will want it for Taddei, Valletti
and the little recorded Carla Gavazzi.
see also review
by Robert J Farr