Error processing SSI file

Herbert von Karajan (1908-1989)
Heldensonate (1938)

Paul von Müllerein, piano
Volk-Kreuzer VK 38-001
DDD 41 minutes, Full Price (Eur 16) from:
Recorded, 25th November 2002

Karajan’s deposition to the Austrian denazification examining board in March 1946 outlines in some detail his membership of the NSDAP and the problems he had after 1939 in becoming a ‘representative "German conductor"’. It fails to mention his single contribution as a composer – his 1938 Heldensonate (Hero Sonata), a work which Karajan, a considerable pianist in his youth (he began learning at the age of 3), and a frequent accompanist in his later years, composed shortly after the German invasion of Austria, and which he had originally titled Anschluß Sonate.

Its origins are less than honourable, being in part down to his ambitious desire to ingratiate himself with the Nazi hegemony which he saw as a surefooted way of developing his own career within Germany. This was especially the case after a 1935 performance of Tristan which drew the ever-lasting wrath of Furtwängler himself, but brought Karajan to the attention of Goebbels and Hitler. Indeed, Karajan was one of only a few top-flight conductors to join the Nazi Party – Schillings and Hausegger being even more pro-Nazi than the Wünderkind – but at the time its benefits were considerable. He was certainly held in higher regard than Knappertsbusch (‘a military band leader’, according to Hitler) and Böhm (‘second-rate’ bellowed the Führer) but Karajan’s world collapsed in 1939 following a gala performance of Die Meistersinger in the presence of Hitler and the Yugoslav prince regent at the Berlin State Opera. Stories as to why the performance went wrong differ but Hitler had no doubt it was because of Karajan’s practice of conducting from memory; es war zur Öffentlichkeit sowie die Sänger extrem unüberlegt’ (it was extremely inconsiderate to the public as well as the singers), he reportedly said. It cost Karajan a job in Dresden that went instead to Elmendorff.

It could be argued that Karajan’s Heldensonate, which was performed in 1938 at one of the Wahnfried receptions Hitler attended annually, had more to do with his alienation than that epoch-defining performance of Meistersinger little more than a year later. Hitler’s notorious indifference towards modern music, and his view that ‘fate’ had not produced any worthwhile German composers after Wagner, probably played a part in Karajan’s gradual freezing from his earlier promise. It was certainly unwise of the young Karajan to choose a heroic title for his work since Hitler was hopeful that it might be on the same memorial scale, even though it was principally a sonata, that Gottfried Müller’s Deutsches Heldenrequiem (1934) had been.

The idea that Karajan’s sonata might be a Zeitgemälde proved disappointing, not least because if you hear this work it proves to be so obviously deficient in inventiveness and sheer scale for the monumental events it is trying to depict, a shattering blow to the German view of art as a symbol of Germany’s greater thousand year reich. Prokofiev proved to be a much greater composer at symbolising through the piano the great events that shaped the Russian war during the early 1940s than any German composer of the same period. There are no military marches, no declamatory chords shadowing the heavy-jackbooted soldiers raping the Austrian landscape. In Karajan’s opening allegro the mood is almost pastoral, more reflective of a Viennese sleepiness, almost as if Karajan is drawing a peaceful arc over much greater events. Perhaps the heroism is more Austrian than German, and it is perhaps this which made Hitler feel so uncomfortable at the performance of the work he attended. Indeed, Winifred Wagner noted in a letter to Goebbels that Hitler seemed ‘almost induced to a comatose state by Herr Karajan’s sonata’.

The central adagio is the longest movement – at almost twenty minutes taking up half the sonatas entire timing. It is indeed pedestrian with slowly evoked single chords sparingly played between similarly sparse pauses. If it resembles in its focus a requiem it is because Karajan occasionally gives an almost hymnal quality to the lower bass chords of the piano part. The final movement, at five minutes, is a waltz which whirls beautifully, if sometimes over-controlled and over-mannered, to a joyous conclusion.

Karajan, a man not known for his irony, may well have been making a point about his own Austrian ancestry. The heroes he depicts through the understatement of the piano writing are perhaps the Austrians themselves. Everything about the sonata suggests life going on as normal, that even after invasion little can shatter the determination of a people to be subjected to the imprisonment of false ideals; there is certainly little to suggest that the title of the work is a reference to the ‘heroic’ Germans, and much to suggest otherwise.

The work’s poor reception at its first hearing effectively shelved it from further performance and this recording of it is the only one I know of. Paul von Müllerein’s performance of it is extremely fine and detailed. Recorded last year, but released propitiously last month, it seems ironic that a conductor condemned for his nationalist sympathies has in fact been able to produce a work that illuminates, with some integrity, a greater belief in the rights of people who suffer at the hands of others.

Dietrich Zaum




Error processing SSI file

Return to Index

Error processing SSI file