Your clickable banner could be here: details If you cannot see an advert click here.
rotating banners
Early Music

Classical Editor: Rob Barnett                               Founder Len Mullenger

Georg Friedrich HAENDEL (1685-1759)
Aci, Galatea e Polifemo - cantata a tre HWV 72 (1708)
Aci: Sandrine Piau (sop)
Galatea: Sara Mingardo (alto)
Polifemo: Laurent Naouri (bass)
Le Concert d’Astrée
Emmanuelle Haïm (harpsichord and direction)
Rec: December 2002, Salle de répétition de l'Orchestre National d'Ile-de-France.
VIRGIN CLASSICS 7243 5 45557 2 5 [98.58]


Crotchet   AmazonUK   AmazonUS


Aci, Galatea e Polifemo is a cantata for three singers written in 1708 when Handel was in Naples. While the story is the same as the English Acis and Galatea, Handel recycled very little for the English Acis. He did, however, adapt some of this music for other operas.

This work is relatively demanding on the singers. The role of Polifemo is extremely wide in range, from treble A down to a very low D, but bass Laurent Naouri is in his element here, and covers this range with ease. The other two singers, soprano Sandrine Piau and alto Sara Mignardo, are very good, though their overuse of vibrato can be annoying. This is especially the case when they sing together and their vibrato is out of phase. It's a bit of a shame, because Sara Mignardo has one of the richest, most intense alto voices I have heard in recent years, and her excessive vibrato detracts from the quality of her voice.

This work features some vintage Handel, with some fine, moving arias. Qui l'augel da pianta in pianta is a nearly perfect piece of music, with a delightful flute opening, then the remainder of the instruments joining, as if it were a concerto, and finally the ethereal soprano voice of Sandrine Piau floating over the instruments. This long aria - nearly 11 minutes - is a perfect example of Handel's brilliant composition for voice, and while very demanding is performed brilliantly.

Bass Laurent Naouri shows his range in the extremely demanding aria Fra l'ombre e gl'orrori, where he slides from tenor to bass with apparent ease (though I'm sure this is much more difficult than he makes it sound). Handel clearly had a fine bass when he composed this work, and used it as a showcase.

But this recording suffers from some weaknesses in sound. At times it sounds like a live recording, with voices or instruments fading away or with voices unbalanced in duets. The opening duet, Sorge il di, shows these problems from the beginning, as the two voices sound as if they came from other recording locations and were overdubbed. The reverb sounds different between the voices, and they carry a somewhat artificial sound over the instruments. Qui l'augel da pianta in pianta has problems, with the voice at times being overwhelmed by the instruments. The aria for bass and continuo, Impara, ingrata, impara, is poorly balanced as well: the harpsichord sounds as though it is in another room, and the balance between the cello and harpsichord is poor.

Instrumentally this music shines. The ensemble plays with precision and verve, and the instruments are balanced perfectly. The opening overture (taken from the Concerto Grosso no. 4 in F major) whets the listeners' appetite with its bouncy rhythms and almost perfect mix. The obbligato instruments, such as the oboe in several of the arias, are recorded almost perfectly.

This recording is very good, and the work itself is excellent, but if one is not a fan of excessive vibrato it can grate. The minor sound problems are easily forgotten, though, and one can easily become carried away by this spectacular work and forget its minor flaws.
Kirk McElhearn

Return to Index

Untitled Document

Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.