Aureole etc.

Golden Age singers

Nimbus on-line

Faure songs
Charlotte de Rothschild (soprano);

  Founder: Len Mullenger
Classical Editor: Rob Barnett


Crotchet   AmazonUK   AmazonUS Bargain price

Jaques OFFENBACH (1819-1875)
Hoffmans Erzahlungen (Les Contes d’Hoffman) opera in 3 Acts with Prologue and Epilogue. (sung in German)
Hoffman, Rudolf Schock (ten); Lindorf/Dapertutto/Coppelius/Dr Miracle, Alexander Welitsch (; Olympia, Wilma Lipp (sop); Giulietta, Martha Modl (m.sop); Antonia, Elfride Trotschel (sop); Stella, Annelie Jansen (sop); Nicklaus, Maria von Ilosvay (m.sop); Spalazini, Willy Hoffman (ten); Crespel, Otto von Rohr (bass); Hermann, Walther Schonfield (bass); Nathanael, Ernst-August Steinhoff (ten); Andrea/Cochenille, Alexander Welitsch (
Kolner Rundfunk Chorus and Orchestra/Eugen Szenkár
Recorded 28th September-1st October 1950. North West German Radio Studio, Köln
RELIEF CR 1902 [3CDs: 57.23+75.19+45.18]

The life of Jacques Offenbach is nearly as complicated and tragic as his last, and greatest, work, ‘The Tales of Hoffmann’. Jacques was originally Jacob, born in Cologne the son of a jobbing Jewish fiddler cum music teacher. The son revealed such early talent that the father made many sacrifices to send his son to study in Paris. There he, in turn, scraped a living as a ‘session’, in today’s idiom, cellist. At the time of the ‘World Exhibition’ in Paris in 1855, frustrated by inability to get his compositions performed, he had opened the minuscule ‘Bouffes Parisiens’ theatre. Visitors to ‘The Exhibition’ flocked to hear his tuneful operettas. As one successful work followed another he was dubbed by Rossini ‘The Mozart of the Champs Elysées’. This frivolous time in France finished abruptly with the Franco-Prussian war, the siege of Paris, the fall of the Emperor Napoleon and the collapse of the ‘Second Empire’. Perhaps Offenbach with his Germanic guttural French felt his day in France was over. He went to America still harbouring a wish to write an opera; one that would be accepted and performed at Paris’s Opéra Comique.

On his return to Paris, another composer generously ceded Offenbach the libretto of Hoffmann. He set to work on the plot which tells the story of Hoffmann’s loves and of his nemesis, Dr Lindorf, who assumes the disguises of Coppelius, Dapertutto and Dr Miracle. Lindorf thwarts his pursuit of the ladies of the story. Hoffmann is rescued from the machinations, and worst intentions, of Lindorf by his companion Nicklaus. As financial necessity involved Offenbach producing other work during the period of composition, progress on Hoffmann was slow and aggravated by the composer’s declining health. At his death he had only orchestrated the Prologue and Act I. The remainder of the work was in piano score and was orchestrated by Ernest Guiraud (he who set the dialogue of Carmen as sung recitative). The work was presented at the Opéra Comique on February 10th 1881. It ran for over one hundred performances in that first season. However, the convoluted story does not end there. Others added spoken dialogue, altered the sequence of the acts, and their location, as well as setting sung recitatives to replace the spoken dialogue. This recording reverts to the original sequence of acts. At the time of this recording, scholarship had not led to the Oeser performing edition, or the 350 or so pages that emerged after that and which are included in Jeffrey Tate’s recording on three Philips CDs. It is very abbreviated compared even with the Decca issue under Bonynge which, like this, is on two CDs.

None of the foregoing is found in the accompanying booklet, which comprises artist profiles, in German and English, and a track listing; distinctly sparse! The artist profiles are informative although that of the conductor is over-hyped. The track numbering is perverse with CD1 tracked 1 to 20 with the aria details in German only. CD2 is detailed as 21 to 44! On playing, the tracks appear on the CD player’s display as 1 to 24; just as one might expect.

The conducting is rather heavily Teutonic at the outset, but the beat becomes lighter, the rhythms better sprung and more idiomatic as the work progresses. I found the introduction to Act III (CD2 tr.10 but shown as 30) very slow and pedantic. This speed tests the Antonia of Elfride Trotschel (1913-1958) as well as highlighting some concerns about pitch and an edginess in what is otherwise a clear, forward and airy recording. It is distinctly better than many from that period.

As to whether Offenbach intended Hoffmann’s loves to be sung by one singer is open to debate. On record, Joan Sutherland (Decca under Bonynge) brought it off, whilst Gruberova (EMI under Cambreling) didn’t. The four roles have very different vocal demands, just like Lindorf and his manifestations. These are here all sung by Alexander Welitsch (1906-1991), with varying success, although his diction is good throughout. As Dr Lindorf he is rather too Germanic, whilst Coppelius lies too high for his comfort with the voice losing focus at the conclusion of ‘Scintille diamant’. By contrast the head voice he uses in CD2 tr.7 (shown as 27) is nearly a croon. His best showing is as Dr Miracle in the Antonia scene where the part lies well for his voice. Welitsch sounds awesomely and threatingly saturnine in ‘Tu ne chantera plus’ (CD2 Trs.16-18) with Hoffmann and Crespel, the latter having a particularly appealing and sonorous bass voice.

Of Hoffmann’s loves, Wilma Lipp (b.1925) is a convincing Olympia. Her ‘Les oiseaux dans la charmelle’ (CD1 tr.14) is well sung with a good trill and well coloured coloratura if without the absolute security of Sutherland in the more stratospheric vocal heights. In the Venetian scene Martha Modl (1912-2001), already a Carmen and to be a Brunnhilde, is a big-voiced Giulietta trying too hard to lighten her innately refulgent tone. The part does not sit well on her voice although one senses the power within that comes into play as she battles with Dapertutto (CD2 tr.7). I have touched on the Antonia of Trotschel: her duet with Hoffmann ‘C’est un chanson d’amour’ (CD2 tr.14) shows her tonal strengths better than the introductory aria. She sings convincingly although her diction could be better.

The part of Hoffmann himself is taken by the German lyric tenor Rudolf Schock (1915-1986). After having his career interrupted to serve on the Russian Front in World War 2 and surviving to sing Tamino at the Vienna State Opera in the 1943/44 season he was called up again for Hitler’s last throw, the Ardennes offensive of December 1944. After the conclusion of hostilities he was engaged at the Staatsoper Berlin. In 1948 became the first German singer engaged by London’s Royal Opera House in the post-war period. There he proved an accomplished Rodolfo. He went on to sing at Salzburg as Idomeneo and extended his fach to include Manrico (Il Trovatore) and Walther (Der Meistersinger). He is well known for his operetta recordings made for EMI Electrola in the late-1940s where his flexible well supported mellifluous tenor is heard to good effect. His potential beyond that lighter repertoire was quickly recognised and he sang his first Hoffmann in 1947. His strengths are clearly apparent as he sing the ‘Kleinsach’ story in the Prologue (CD1 tr.4). If he hasn’t quite the heft of Domingo (Decca), the subtleness of his voice, sheer élan and feel for a phrase as well as characterisation are virtues preferable to Gedda (EMI) or Schicoff (Philips). His ‘Amis l’amour’ of the Venice scene (CD2 tr.2) shows some slight strain above the stave and he doesn’t have the beauty of tone of Wunderlich. Nonetheless his portrayal is convincing and enjoyable and justifies interest in this issue.

The matter of language will influence some purchasers. For me it was not too much of a problem and it certainly did not detract from my enjoyment of Offenbach’s inspiring music. Any doubts are compensated by hearing well known singers in repertoire other than that which they sang outside their country or on studio recordings.

Robert J Farr



Return to Index

Untitled Document

Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.