Aureole etc.

Golden Age singers

Nimbus on-line

Faure songs
Charlotte de Rothschild (soprano);

  Founder: Len Mullenger
Classical Editor: Rob Barnett


Crotchet   AmazonUK   AmazonUS


Franco ALFANO (1876-1954)
Cyrano de Bergerac - Comédie héroïque en quatre actes (cinq tableaux) (1936)
Manuela Uhl (sop) - Roxane
Jennifer Arnold (mz) - La Duègne et Soeur Marthe
Susanna Bernhard (sop) - Lisa et une soeur
Roman Sadnik (ten) - Cyrano
Wolfgang Newerla (bar) - De Guiche
Simon Pauly (bar) - Carbon, De Valvert, l'officer Espagnol
Paul McNamara (ten) - Christian
Matthias Kelin (bass-bar) - Ragueneau
Bernd Gebhardt (bass-bar) - Le Bret
Konstantin Heintel (bar) - Lignière
Kiel Opera Chorus
Kiel PO/Manuel Frank
Deutschland Radio live, Kiel Opera House, 12, 30 May 2002 DDD
CPO 999 909-2 [2CD: 121.22]

Alfano's reputation rests on his completion of Puccini's Turandot. Out and out opera buffs will know or know of his operas Risurezzione (1903) and La Leggenda di Sakuntala (1914-20) either in full or in aria-extract. I am grateful to Amanda Holden's 'New Penguin Opera Guide' for further background information. From this I can say that Alfano was born in the Naples region of Italy. He studied in Naples, Leipzig and briefly in Paris and Berlin.

The final decision about the Alfano completion of Turandot fell to Toscanini who made many cuts and adjustments to Alfano’s work. We were only able to hear Alfano's unbowdlerised version on 3 November 1982 after forceful advocacy by the critic Mosco Carner. Alfano's star plunged further towards oblivion because of his fascist associations. A whole generation of actual or perceived Axis composers (including Korngold, Zemlinsky, Schreker, Schillings and Pfitzner - some dreadful irony in that list) had their music almost erased for many decades. Indeed Alfano's greatest hit Sakuntala could only be revived in Pesaro because Alfano had to rewrite the score because the original score and orchestral material had been obliterated when the Allied bombing of Milan destroyed the Ricordi archives in 1942.

The plot of Cyrano is based on a novella by Henri Cain after Edmond Rostand's play. Cain was the librettist of Massenet's Navarraise, Sapho, Cendrillon, Chérubin, Don Quichotte and Roma. Alfano was attracted to the subject but Cain's fee was felt to be unreasonably high. After a long flirtatious negotiation the contract was signed in 1933 and finished in 1935 in line with Alfano's agreement with Kalmus.

The story is fairly well known but here it is in outline. The backdrop is the period 1640 to 1700. France is at war with the Spanish invader. Cyrano is in undeclared love with Roxane. Roxane falls in love with Christian. Roxane get Cyrano to promise that he will protect Christian in battle. Cyrano helps the obtuse and awkward Christian woo Roxane with eloquent letters. Cyrano is in torment. Christian finally realises that Cyrano loves Roxane and in battle insists Cyrano should tell Roxane all. Before he can do this Christian is brought back from the field dying of his wounds and Cyrano keeps his secret. Roxane retires to a convent and years later Cyrano visits her after a fight in which he has taken a clubbed blow to the head. He is fatally wounded but conceals his wounds from her. He reads to her Christian's last letter but adds so much to it that Roxane at long last comes to know that he loves her and has always loved her. She always loved the writer of those precious beguiling letters and now knows it is Cyrano. As is the way with these plots Cyrano dies.

The libretto is in French and so it is sung here. The world premiere nevertheless took place in Rome conducted by Tullio Serafin with Barthelémy Gheusi (at ease in both Italian and French) as Cyrano and Maria Caniglia as Roxane. There were performances shortly afterwards in Paris and then, in Leipzig and Erfurt in German translation in 1942.

This is one of those operas where there is a great deal of singing ... if that doesn’t sound completely fatuous. Indeed there are seventy pages of libretto; all double columned. The solo voices are engaged at most times; comparatively short commons for the chorus. Across the whole opera there are three orchestral introductions but these last less than five minutes put together.

Alfano, at this stage in his career, was writing in an opulently tonal style. Everything is lyrically singable. His orchestral palette is overflowingly affluent but rarely loud. He seems to revel in tones suggestive of silks, damasks, purple, gold and silver cloths, iridescence, numinous effects and translucent texturing. He belongs in the company of such orchestral mages as Zemlinsky, Korngold Die Kathrin, Die Tote Stadt and Violanta), Schoeck (more the orchestral and vocal brilliance of Massimilla Doni and Schloss Durande than the brutal originality of Penthesilea) and Schreker (Die Gezeichneten and Die Ferne Klang). At this stage Alfano had nothing to prove. He was master of his craft. He was having no truck with Berg and Schoenberg except perhaps the early expressionism of Schoenberg's Gurrelieder.

The Germanic names I have mentioned should not distract us from other even more helpful parallels. Cain might well have provided librettos for Massenet however it is a later generation whose names and musical lingua franca come to mind when hearing Cyrano. Alfano avoids the dense but intoxicating effects of Florent Schmitt. He is closer to Ropartz in Le Pays (1910) and to Roussel in Padmavâtî (1918) stripped of the Oriental exoticisms. Another French composer who presents yet closer parallels is the Breton Lazzari in his verismo opera La Lépreuse (now there's a project for CPO, along with Atterberg's opera Fanal, 1934). Closer to home (Alfano's home) we may quite properly think of another Italian operatic practitioner slighted by the post-War establishment, Ottorino Respighi. Alfano's orchestral skills had also been honed through study of the scores of both Ravel and Debussy. I wondered about parallels between Cyrano and Pelléas et Mélisande but while the notes speak of this opera as a vast 'symphonic poem' there is too much variety and dramaturgical spirit in Cyrano to make much of a link with Debussy's opera. There is no levity in this work. It is serious and tender, exuberant and joyous, ecstatic and often spell-binding. There are many bejewelled moments but it is flawed. The flaw is in the finish. The fourth and final act lasts only twenty minutes after its predecessors running to 17, 53 and 30 minutes respectively. That final act lacks the great emotional pay-off that Puccini might have brought to it. The ending, which is one of grand tragedy, needs more emotional stuffing - a slashing blow of tragic fate sustained or built over the twenty minutes. Somehow this eludes Alfano. I compare this with listening to Korngold's Die Kathrin, Schreker's Die Gezeichneten and Zemlinsky's Der Traumgörge. All of these build and seize the final climactic moments. Alfano lets them pass in a modest downbeat gesture that is far too undemonstrative.

In doing this he defies the many succinctly built emotional climaxes and wonderful episodes that occur throughout this grand lyrical and impressionistic opera. I mention only a few of many. The battlefield trumpets are brilliantly done in true Korngoldian style at 00.48 tr. 6 CD2. Roxane’s realisation of Cyrano’s love is superbly caught in her aria Je lisais (CD2 tr. 8) in which Manuela Uhl grips this Tosca-like moment with full majesty. This is wondrously fresh climax that will appeal to you if you appreciate Vissi d'arte. The playful prelude to Act 1 is like a light-handed version of Petrushka. However this is a romantic opera and if we wish to be reminded of this then sample tracks 29 and 30 (tous mes appels d'amour) of CD1. This is lush writing, reeking of characteristics we now unfairly associate with Hollywood (due to the émigrés who trekked there to make their livings). That the experience proved so joyful is high tribute to all involved and I cannot help singling out for special laurels Uhl and Sadnik as well as the virtuoso work of the Kiel Philharmonic under their sympathetic conductor Markus Frank.

The substantial booklet notes with this set are by Andreas K.W. Meyer, Konrad Dryden (biographer of Zandonai and Leoncavallo) and the conductor Markus Frank. These notes (though flecked with typos - at least in the English translation) are a thorough traversal of Cyrano, its background and the close and distant context. The booklet runs to 147 pages.

The two hour opera is generously tracked - 32 on CD1 and 17 on CD2. The libretto which runs the sung French side by side with the English translation itself cues the text to the tracks. The notes are given in German translation but there is no such favour for the libretto. No sign of any Italian anywhere. The booklet carries illustrations (about ten plates) from the Kiel Opera production (a fairly subdued minimalist approach by all appearances) from which this recording derives as well as three historical Alfano photographs. It is all extremely well done and while you are enjoying this recording you will be able to catch the full flavour and setting of the opera.

This is not the first commercial recording though it is almost certainly its first appearance on CD. The work was recorded on the MRF label in 1975.

Quite a triumph leaving us licking our lips for Sakuntala, Risurezzione, Don Juan de Mañara, Madonna Imperia and L'Ultimo Lord.

Rob Barnett


Miranda (1896)
La fonte di Enschir (1898)
Risurezzione (1903)
Il Principe Zilah (1909)
L'Ombra di Don Giovanni (later revised as Don Juan de Mañara - not to be confused with Eugene Goossens' 1930s opera of the same name) (1914, rev. 1941)
Sakuntala (1914-1920)
Madonna Imperia (1927)
L'Ultimo Lord (1930)
Cyrano de Bergerac (1936)
Il dottor Antonio (1949)

Gerard Hoffnung CDs

Advertising on

Donate and get a free CD

New Releases

Naxos Classical


Musicweb sells the following labels
Acte Préalable
Cameo Classics
Northern Flowers
Toccata Classics

Follow us on Twitter

Subscribe to our free weekly review listing

Sample: See what you will get

Return to Index

Untitled Document

Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.