Aureole etc.

Golden Age singers

Nimbus on-line

Faure songs
Charlotte de Rothschild (soprano);

  Founder: Len Mullenger
Classical Editor: Rob Barnett


Crotchet   AmazonUK   AmazonUS

Busoni recalled. The 1941 New York commemorative concert
Wolfgang Amadeus MOZART (1756-1791)

Idomeneo Overture arranged by Ferruccio Busoni in 1918
Ferruccio BUSONI (1866-1924)

Indian Fantasy for Piano and Orchestra (1915)
Sarabande and Cortège Op 51 (1918-19)
Violin Concerto in D Op 35a (1896-97)
Josef Szigeti recalls Busoni (from a talk given at Harvard University in 1965)
Egon Petri (piano)
Josef Szigeti (violin)
Philharmonic-Symphony Orchestra of New York/Dimitri Mitropoulos
Recorded live at Carnegie Hall, New York 28 December 1941
MUSIC AND ARTS CD 1052 [72.49]


This New York commemorative concert was fortuitously recorded and the discs owned by the New England Conservatory of Music. Luckily there seem to have been at least two turntables in use because, despite the resultant pitch fluctuations there doesnít sound to have been any loss of music. Pitch and other problems have been dealt with by Dimitrios Antsos and the whole production has been overseen by Maggi Payne. So, a caveat to begin with - there is the usual array of acetate scuffs and surface noise and obviously some sound constriction. As broadcasts go however, and this is a significant one, the fidelity is creditable.

It had been 75 years since Busoniís birth and the concert was graced by a trio of musicians who had known him to varying degrees; Petri the longest, Szigeti who championed the Violin Concerto and also the Second Sonata and Mitropoulos who had been introduced to Busoni by Petri in Berlin in 1920. It was an idiosyncratic touch to open the concert with Busoniís arrangement of the overture to Idomeneo. This was a work Busoni had only come across a couple of years before he met Mitropoulos but he set to work with enthusiasm, creating a concert suite comprising the Overture, Sacrificial scene and Festal March. The commemorative concert began with the Overture Ė boldly and vigorously etched. Egon Petri was perhaps the greatest of all Busoniís followers and his contribution was the Indian Fantasy. Busoniís interest had first been piqued as early as 1910 and the Indian Dairy appeared five years later Ė a set of four piano studies and also an orchestral study Ė whilst the Fantasy dates from 1913-15. Petri announces his credentials right from the opening section - glittering panache but intensely concentrated sound Ė but heís equally a master of linearity in Busoniís writing. The sectionality of the piece Ė its dance and lament profile and the hieratic barbarism sometimes unleashed Ė is compellingly coalesced in Petriís hands, aided in no small measure by Mitropoulosís shaping of the romantic interludes. Here he encourages some scintillatingly expressive string playing; sepulchral basses too. But itís that G major song in the second section that most catches in the mind. Petri voices it with perfect delicacy and the orchestra answers with almost DvořŠkian relish. The Vivamente section, pulsing and barbarous, with blaring brass and dance rhythms, survives even the relatively primitive recorded sound.

The Sarabande and Cortège came before the interval at the concert. The former is imbued here with an intense solemnity, highlit by its singular tread but also by those shafts of interior beauty. Mitropoulos certainly evokes the heady harmonic ambiguities of the latter where orchestral virtuosity does justice to the demands of rhythm and proper tone. Because the Two Movements from his Suite for Orchestra Geharnischte havenít survived the recital ends with the Violin Concerto. This had been premiered by Henri Petri, father of Egon, in Berlin in 1897. Szigeti had first played it for Busoni in about 1912, the composer ruefully announcing that the work wasnít as bad as heíd remembered it. We have other examples of Szigetiís performances on record; a live RAI performance with Previtali from 1952 is also on Music and Arts and the commercial LP with the Little Orchestral Society under Scherman, from 1954, has appeared on Sony Classical CD. Back in 1941 Szigeti was on fine technical form, his tone characteristically steely but without the depletions that age and illness later wrought. I was especially touched by the way he darkened his lower strings for the elegiac passages and by his commanding intellectual strength. Thereís a fine orchestral tremolando and good tuttis as well. In the central panel, where the soloist spins an unbroken line, Szigetiís rapt intensity is memorable and thereís some good, crisp bowing in the finale where his playing is not burdened by portamenti. A charming snippet of his 1965 Harvard talk closes the disc.

This was a rare occasion in which two of Busoniís special champions were joined by another of lesser intimacy but no less commitment. It has a historical frisson, manages to transcend mere associative allegiances and I found it exceptionally persuasive listening.

Jonathan Woolf



Return to Index

Untitled Document

Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.