£16 post free World-wide

 


555 sonatas 9Cds mp3 files
Only £22


 


Benjamin: Written on Skin £16

Search
What's New
Previous CDs
Concerts
Jazz
Nostalgia
Composers
Resources
Announce
Labels index


Every day we post 10 new Classical CD and DVD reviews. A free weekly summary is available by e-mail. MusicWeb is not a subscription site. To keep it free please purchase discs through our links.

  Classical Editor Rob Barnett    






Julian Bream & John Williams (guitars)
BMG - RCA 74321 846092
[CD1: 70:07; CD2: 74:24]

Crotchet   AmazonUK   AmazonUS  Amazon recommendations

BREAM, WILLIAMS - DUOS DE GUITARES
    WILLIAM LAWES
    Suite for two guitars
  1. Corant I
  2. Alman
  3. Corant II

  4. FERDINANDO CARULLI

    Duo Op. 34 in G
  5. Largo
  6. Rondo

  7. FERNANDO SOR

    L'encouragment Op. 34
  8. Cantabile
  9. Theme & Variations
  10. Waltz

  11. ISAAC ALBENIZ
  12. Cordoba (from Cantos de España Op. 232)

  13. ENRIQUE GRANADOS
  14. Goyescas: Intermezzo

  15. MANUEL DE FALLA
  16. La Vida Breve: Spanish Dance No.1

  17. MAURICE RAVEL
  18. Pavane pour une Infante Defunte

  19. GABRIEL FAURÉ

    Dolly Op.56
  20. Berceuse
  21. Mi-a-ou
  22. Le Jardin de Dolly
  23. Kitty- Valse
  24. Tendresse
  25. Le pas Espagnol

  26. ENRIQUE GRANADOS
  27. Oriental (from Danzas Españolas Op.37)

  28. FERDINANDO CARULLI

    Seranade Op.96
  29. Largo Maestoso: Allegro moderato
  30. Larghetto
  31. Finale

  32. ENRIQUE GRANADOS
  33. Rondella Aragonesa (from Danzas Españolas Op. 37)

  34. ISAAC ALBENIZ
  35. Bajo la Palmera (from Cantos de España Op. 232)

  36. ENRIQUE GRANADOS
  37. Zambra (from Danzas Espanolas Op.37)

  38. MAURO GIULIANI
  39. Variazoni Concertante Op.130

  40. ISAAC ALBENIZ
  41. Evocacion (from Iberia)

  42. JOHN JOHNSON
  43. Pavan
  44. Galliard

  45. GEORG PHILIPP TELEMANN

    Partita Polonaise
  46. Ouverture
  47. Harlequinade
  48. Le Ris
  49. Rigadon
  50. Combattans
  51. Gigue

  52. CLAUDE DEBUSSY
  53. Reverie
  54. Golliwog's Cakewalk
  55. Clair de Lune

The reputations of Julian Bream and John Williams' are undisputed. Individually their interpretations of the guitar's solo repertoire, recordings of concertos for guitar and orchestra plus, with other ensembles, are without question some of the finest performances available. There was an inevitability to their collaboration. However, be clear, these recordings are not an example of great guitar duet playing. Their ensemble is not up to the standard of some of the renowned partnerships in this field such as the late Ida Presti & Alexandre Lagoya or Sergio and Eduardo Abreu and more currently the Assad brothers, Sergio and Odair.

What we have here is two great soloists who are making music together for the sheer enjoyment of it. This comes across in these recordings. Indeed I seem to recall Bream saying that for their first album they sight-read the music whilst recording. If this is the case then the result is an achievement in itself. Usually it takes years to develop a high level of rapport between two players.

In 1971 the first album of Julian Bream and John Williams "Together" was my introduction to guitar duet playing. I still regularly listen to this with fondness. This experience led me to the investigation of Presti & Lagoya, the Abreus and the like. In 1973 there followed "Together Again" and, in 1979, "Julian Bream & John Williams Live" a two record set recorded in America the previous year.

This French double CD set is made up of material from all three of these vinyl releases *. Both discs were released separately with identical track listings but with audience applause deleted on Compact Disc in 1993 (RCA 09026 61450 2 and RCA 09026 61452 2 respectively). The live recordings were available in CD format on RCA RD 89645, minus the encore, "Oriental" by Granados; presumably necessitated by lack of space.

The present digital re-mastering retains the sense of intimacy crucial in a recording of this kind. Background hiss is present, but if a realistic volume is used is unobtrusive. These discs do not supply details of the stereo placement of the two guitarists, so after consulting my old vinyl albums I can disclose, for those interested, that Julian Bream is on the right and John Williams on the left.

As one might expect, all the music is played with the assured air of two experienced recording artists. The early music, represented by John Johnson and William Lawes (transcribed by Bream), has all the hallmarks of his enthusiasm for the period.

Both Williams and Bream have recorded music of the baroque, notably that of J S Bach, Scarlatti and Cimarosa. Prior to this time in their careers neither had recorded any of the works of Georg Philipp Telemann, who, in my opinion, is underestimated. Apart from allegedly being the most prolific composer ever his standards often equalled, if not exceeded that of his contemporaries. Bream and Williams deliver some of their most spontaneous playing with his "Partita Polonaise". This is in six movements scored for two lutes. It was written during a stay in Poland and is one of the first pieces to use the traditions of folkdance.

The classical selections of the guitarist/composers Sor, Carulli and Giuliani, written as guitar duets, display joyful interplay. Fernando Sor wrote "L'Encouragement" as a duet for teacher and pupil, with the teacher taking the more demanding part and the pupil taking the easier accompaniment. It is presented here in an arrangement that shares the 1st and 2nd guitar parts in a more democratic way, giving the individual guitarists an opportunity to shine.

Spanish composers have always been a source of inspiration for what is regarded, after all, as their national instrument. The piano works of Albeniz and Granados abound with the romantic flavour of the Iberian peninsular. These pieces are augmented by Manuel de Falla's earthy "Spanish Dance No.1" from the composer's opera "La Vida Breve". This is definitely one of the high points of the collection. The nuances of French impressionism are not lost in transcription from piano to guitar duet. Gabriel Fauré's "Dolly Suite" misses none of its charm. Even if the Bream and Williams rendition of Debussy's "Clair de Lune" does not match the Presti/Lagoya version, remember, for a live recording by two players who do not make up a regular partnership, this is pretty good stuff.

One sour note relates to the presentation. The front cover artwork is so inappropriate as to be untrue. The gross error at the start of the liner notes is indefensible. Doesn't RCA have proof- readers to check such things while in production.

Apart from that, this collection is a fine historical document of two of the finest classical guitarists of their generation each enjoying the musicianly company. This is essential listening for anybody remotely interested in classical guitar music.


Andy Daly


 
*Missing from this compilation are three of the works recorded live, these are-
Fernando Sor Fantasia, Op.54
Johannes Brahms Thème et Variations, Op.18
Isaac Albeniz Castilla (from 'Cantos de España') Op. 232


Return to Index

Untitled Document


Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.