Aureole etc.

Golden Age singers

Nimbus on-line

Faure songs
Charlotte de Rothschild (soprano);

  Founder: Len Mullenger
Classical Editor: Rob Barnett

FEEL THE SPIRIT: Songs and Spirituals
Feel the Spirit, seven spirituals
George SHEARING Songs and sonnets from Shakespeare
John RUTTER The heavenly aeroplane
John RUTTER (arr) Lord of the Dance
John RUTTER Birthday madrigals
Hoagy CARMICHAEL arr John RUTTER Skylark

Margaret Marshall (mezzo) Wayne Marshall (piano)
The Cambridge Singers, BBC Concert Orchestra John Rutter.
Cambridge, 2000? (DDD)

Crotchet   AmazonUK   AmazonUS  Amazon recommendations


I used to think that John Rutter was the Andrew Lloyd Webber of modern church music. How utterly wrong I have been proved to be!

The Second Viennese School, with those geniuses Schoenberg, Berg and particularly Webern, turned their back on diatonic melody. Such melody is usually confined to a scale of 7 notes and, while I am not a mathematician, the permutations of these notes to form an original diatonic melody today is non-existent when you calculate all the music written from Plainsong to the modern day. Mozart wrote about 650 works, Haydn about 2000. And what of Beethoven, Handel, Brahms, Schubert, Mendelssohn et al. How many melodies did these great composers write between them; not to mention the remainder of them?

This is one of the many reasons why pop music is so awful. The melodies are not original. Take the Beatles... you are welcome to them. I remember a great musician saying to us, "The only qualification for being a pop singer is the inability to sing!" As a schoolteacher I have to take an interest in what children like today and so I listen and watch a lot of pop music. I have yet to find one pop star who can sing in tune. There are plenty of bawlers, shouters, snarlers and those who wobble around notes because they are not sure of it!

As to Gospel music I hate the clapping, jigging and the endless singing of the same words over and over again and someone talking over it in a semi-rap style. This is typical of Pentecostal, Charismatic and House groups. It is so disorganised and indeterminate. Utterly confusing and, if a Biblical verse can be used to support my view, God is not the author of confusion. Modern day worship has degenerated into 'anything goes' - a type of disorder.

But here John Rutter presents spirituals, which is Gospel music, in a beautifully crafted and organised way. This is pure music. One can hear the words. The progress of the music, which has logic is clearly defined. There is no clapping and stomping of feet … halleluia! … and no voice-over rap … Thank God!

The performance of Deep River is absolutely choice. The tempo, the diction, the clarity, the simple but effective harmonies, make it so moving that I have played this track to death. Now this is a spiritual experience. And Margaret Marshall is superb. I adored the men’s syncopated rhythm in The Battle of Jericho but the class act is Every time I feel the Spirit, which also includes another spiritual within it. Note the contrasts and the sheer joy ... and not the clapping!! The climax is staggering. I have played this track to death as well.

George Shearing is a magnificent jazz pianist but I am undecided about his Shakespeare settings. They are very pleasant but somewhat bland. And the problem of originality again looms large. One song sounds like the hymn tune Dix, namely As with gladness men of old. Well might the producers say that these songs were deliberately written in well used styles. If you are going to write in an already existing style you have to introduce some striking originality. When I wrote my symphony to commemorate the 250th anniversary of the death of Haydn I had his style in mind as well as parts for saxophone, cornet and tuba playing a duet with a piccolo.

John Rutter’s The Heavenly Aeroplane has an absolutely absurd text which offends many Christians and I can understand why. It is written in a rock n’ roll style and I was beginning to admire Rutter.

Lord of the Dance has another absurd text and is an attempt by the early precursors of Pentecostals to justify dance in Christian worship.

The Birthday Sonnets fall into the same category as Shearing’s songs. There are very pleasant but easy listening and only easy listening. Nothing great here.

The disc ends with an arrangement of Hoagy Carmichael’s Skylark which is very welcome.

An interesting disc and an important one to show that the singing of spirituals and Gospel music can be far more enjoyable when sung properly than in some ramshackle gospel choir clapping, clicking their figures and being repetitive.

Well done, Mr Rutter

David Wright

Return to Index

Untitled Document

Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.