£16 post free World-wide

 


555 sonatas 9Cds mp3 files
Only £22


 


Benjamin: Written on Skin £16

Search
What's New
Previous CDs
Concerts
Jazz
Nostalgia
Composers
Resources
Announce
Labels index


Every day we post 10 new Classical CD and DVD reviews. A free weekly summary is available by e-mail. MusicWeb is not a subscription site. To keep it free please purchase discs through our links.

  Classical Editor Rob Barnett    



Kurt ATTERBERG (1887-1974)
Symphony No 7, Op 45 (1941/2) "Sinfonia Romantica"
Symphony No 8, Op 48 (1944/45)

SWR Radio-Sinfonieorchester Stuttgart/Ari Rasilainen
Rec 2000, Stuttgart
CPO 999 641-2 [62.43]


Crotchet   AmazonUK   AmazonUS  
Amazon recommendations



The Swedish composer Kurt Atterberg has tended to be remembered as a composer of the inter-war years, though writing in an idiom which often suggests the music was written earlier. Earning his living as a civil servant in the Swedish patent office, Atterberg nevertheless composed a remarkably large catalogue of romantic music with a distinctive voice, often touched by the sound of Swedish folk music. His output includes nine symphonies, orchestral works, various choral works (the ninth symphony, Sinfonia Visionaria is for soloists, chorus and orchestra), a delightful string quartet, concertos and operas.

A nationalist composer if ever there was one, Atterberg backed the wrong political horse during the Second World War, and although living in a country that was not occupied, he accepted performances of his music in Nazi Germany, including the premieres of the two symphonies under review. Misguided opportunism possibly, but most of his music consequently had to wait a quarter century after the war before being heard again, and Atterberg’s later music has only occasionally been heard since, and is only now being revived.

In 1972, two years before Atterberg died, an American friend, the late Bennett Tarshish, critic and record collector, interviewed Atterberg in Stockholm. Atterberg took Tarshish to a chamber music recital promoted by a music society whose meetings the composer claimed to have attended without break since 1908. Before Roussel’s String Trio he whispered to his guest ‘very disagreeable piece’. The truth was that Atterberg was a traditionalist composer, albeit with his own voice, who venerated the models of the past.

Neither of these wartime symphonies rise to the level of his earlier successes, the Second, Third and Sixth Symphonies, the latter, of course, the work which won the Columbia Graphophone Company’s 1928 Schubert Centennial Competition. As war works, neither of them seems to pay much attention to the times, possibly the composer’s reaction to a disintegrating world was to keep the blinkers firmly on.

As far as I know neither of these symphonies made it to LP, but both have been previously recorded on CD (Sterling CDS 1026-2) in a pioneering recording by Malmö forces under Mikhail Jurowski. Before that the complete unknown was the seventh symphony, but some enthusiasts may have come across the Eighth - there is a recording by the Swedish Radio Symphony Orchestra dating from 1960 in the Swedish Radio sound archive and another by the Helsingborg Symphony Orchestra and Lennart Hedwall did the rounds on tape some twenty five or more years ago.

The Seventh Symphony of 1941-42 in fact quarries Atterberg’s opera Fanal which had been written immediately after his Sixth Symphony - the then notorious "dollar" symphony - in 1929-32, and so it is not surprising that he should exhibit melodic and textual reminiscences of the earlier symphonies in the first movement of the three-movement seventh. Overall, I am afraid I found it no great discovery, and it strikes me as Atterberg’s weakest symphonic work. The opening movement is very much the curtain-up on a costume drama, the opening bombast not hopeful for what is to follow. Though the thematic material here, once we are fully underway is very much the world of the sixth symphony, and not without its pleasing moments. But it is the finale that lets it down so badly, I found it remarkably trite - the combination of folksy dancing rhythms and colourful orchestration is an idiom Atterberg usually relishes and it should be successful and may well be so on stage, but here it seems so corny that one wonders if it should be followed by a more substantial finale - and, indeed CPO’s annotator tells us there was indeed once a fourth movement which Atterberg deleted.

In contrast, the Eighth Symphony of 1944-45 works much better; stronger invention, the folk-derived themes working really well. This is a delightful addition to the Atterberg canon. The slow-movement’s cor anglais solo is a gem, while the dancing Vivo scherzo and the catchy themes in the finale, even if much of it is a lot of business about nothing, all add up to a charming work - as much ‘Sinfonia Romantica’ as the Seventh - and it would be good to hear a live performance.

The disc is timed at 63:33 on the box, but the CD readout is 62:43. If you did not get the Sterling version and want to complete your Atterberg Symphonies this can be recommended, but if you just want to explore the best of Atterberg, go for the earlier symphonies.


Lewis Foreman


Return to Index

Untitled Document


Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.