Aureole etc.

Golden Age singers

Nimbus on-line

Faure songs
Charlotte de Rothschild (soprano);

  Founder: Len Mullenger
Classical Editor: Rob Barnett

Joaquín RODRIGO (1901-1999)

Piano Concerto (rev. Achúcarro) (1942 rev 1996) [30.29]
Preludio para un poema a la Alhambra (1928) [7.36]
Música para un jardín (1935) [11.11]
Homenaje a La Tempranica (1939) [5.34]
Juglares (1923) [5.26]
Daniel Ligorio Ferrandiz (piano)
Castille y León SO/Max Bragado-Darman
rec Valladolid, July, Nov, 2001, DDD
Complete Orchestral Works: Vol. 4
NAXOS 8.557101 [60.17]


Crotchet   AmazonUK   AmazonUS Superbudget


It is a shame that Rodrigo is only usually known for his guitar music. Naxos are to be congratulated on redressing the balance.

The Piano Concerto started life in 1942 as the Heroic Concerto for piano and orchestra and I think that title should have been retained for it sums up the piece. The pianist Joaquín Achúcarro revised it and suggested corrections as to orchestration and the more discreet use of repetition. This second version was first performed in 1996 with Achúcarro. He is a formidable pianist. I first saw him play Brahms' Piano Concerto no 2 in the Colston Hall, Bristol in 1967 and when I heard Kissin perform it at the 2002 Proms I was horrified. That was a simply dreadful performance.

Rodrigo's concerto is heroic. It sounds like a medieval epic transferred to the Hollywood screen. One expects a dashing Robin Hood or El Cid to appear at any moment and I am afraid some of the music is so Hollywoodish that it is banal. On the other hand the sounds one has become accustomed to of 13th century pageantry as portrayed by film composers is often very stirring. The opening movements are very bright and cheerful if a little schmaltzy at times with braying hunting horns and a grandeur that is not held back by pomposity. The piano writing is virtuosic if a little clichéed.

But the music could be viewed and heard in a different way. If you know the piano concertos by Scharwenka you will get an idea of what to expect although Rodrigo's work does not have the structural soundness of Scharwenka. The Spaniard's concerto sometimes declines into episodic forms but, like the Walton Symphony no. 1, I find this concerto to be somewhat overwhelming in its power and intensity.

Yet there is another argument and consideration. The other famous piano and orchestra work by a Spanish composer is Falla's Nights in the Gardens of Spain which he took seven years to write and the results show that. Falla's work is very flabby. Rodrigo's is not. The piano writing in the Rodrigo is stunning and very well executed. The sound is crystal clear and it is a highly enjoyable and exciting piece. Whether it is durable might be another matter. The Prelude on a poem of the Alhambra owes something to the style of Falla but is redeemed by some imaginative orchestration. It is a better piece than the concerto although not so immediate. It recalls the music of Spain but with a superb orchestration that avoids the clichés of clattering feet, noisy shoes, anaemic guitars and infuriating castanets. There are some excellent rhythmic contrasts and the sultry Spanish heat is expertly caught in the central lento section.

Musica para un jardín is an orchestration of Berceuses for piano of 1935 first performed under the baton of Jose Iturbi in Valencia in 1958. The four movements correspond with the seasons of the year. There are allusions to Spring in the opening prelude and the conclusion. Autumn is depicted by the cor anglais and oboe in the second movement and the horn takes it over in the winter section. There are some wonderful sonorities here but I am not sure the suite works as a whole. Attractive it is but few of us will enthuse about it whereas some will about the Piano Concerto.

The next piece is the prize. Translated it means homage to the precocious girl and is a tribute to Geronimo Gimenez's zarzuela La Tempranica of 1900. Rodrigo wrote this while he was living in Paris and it was originally scored for string orchestra and premiered in Paris in the spring of 1939. It begins with an elegant prelude. This leads into the first theme of the zarzuela followed by a dance and a lively finale. The work was later re-scored for orchestra and premiered in Paris in December 1939. And there is a brief use of the castanets in an otherwise super score.

Juglars is another short essay, Rodrigo's first orchestral piece. It is almost a mini-symphony in ABA form: the outer sections are quick and in the tonality of A with a sad G minor slow section in the middle. The opening snare drum style is a bit off-putting. A charming piece all the same but, sadly, it says little.

David Wright

Gerard Hoffnung CDs

Advertising on

Donate and get a free CD

New Releases

Naxos Classical


Musicweb sells the following labels
Acte Préalable
Cameo Classics
Northern Flowers
Toccata Classics

Follow us on Twitter

Subscribe to our free weekly review listing

Sample: See what you will get

Return to Index

Untitled Document

Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.