Classical CD and DVD reviews. MusicWeb is not a subscription site and it is our advertisers that pay for it. Please visit their sites regularly to see if anything might interest you. Purchasing from them keeps MusicWeb free.

Classical Editor: Rob Barnett                               Founder Len Mullenger


Chapter 2: page 1 page 2 page 3 page 4

 

The Story of Act III

The final act takes place in a room in an hotel: on the left a window, on the right a door leading to a passage: in the centre is the entrance to Marty’s bedroom which is separated by a curtain. Marty enters from the bedroom in a peignoir, closely followed by Prus who wears a dinner jacket but no collar.

As Marty crosses to the window and draws up the blind, Prus sits down dejectedly on a chair. Turning from the window she enquires: "Well? Satisfied?" and asks if she may now have the envelope. Prus takes from his breastpocket a leather pocket-book from which he extracts a sealed envelope and without a word throws it in front of Marty on the table. She pounces on it, examines it by the light of the bed lamp, opens it with a hairpin and, taking from it a yellow faded manuscript, quickly scans it, folds the paper and hides it in her bosom.

Prus remarks dolefully that she has cheated him out of it: she was as cold as ice, like a corpse-and it was for such doubtful pleasure that he has purloined someone else’s letter. Marty tells him not to make such a fuss over a single envelope. If it would make him feel any better, why doesn’t he spit in her face! Rather in his own, retorts Prus bitterly.

There is a knock on the door: a chambermaid enters and announces that Mr. Prus’s servant is enquiring for him. Prus is amazed that anyone should know where he has spent the night. He retires to the bedroom to put on a collar, while Marty sits down in front of the toilet-table and asks the chambermaid to do her hair. Something terrible has happened, the maid says in a thrilling voice to her mistress. Mr. Prus’s servant is in such a state, frightened to death he is: shaking, holding a letter in his hand! Marty, who could not be less interested, yawns, tells the maid to be careful what she is doing with her hair, she is tugging at it.

Prus, now properly dressed, hurriedly re-enters and goes out. Marty tells the chambermaid to concentrate on her hair. The girl, however, continues to chatter until Prus enters abruptly. He is holding a letter in his shaking hands and tells Marty to dismiss the girl. The chambermaid makes a hurried exit as Prus gropes for a chair. The upshot of the matter is that his son has shot himself. He had fallen madly in love with Marty and, being suspicious, followed his father last night: when he found out what was happening... between Prus and Marty....

Prus drops the letter, hut turns on Marty angrily when he finds her quite unconcerned and calmly putting hairpins in her hair. Must she go about like a scarecrow because someone has killed herself for love of her, she replies in some heat. Besides, Prus is at least as much to blame as she is. The tormented father torn between grief and anger storms out, as the feeble-minded Hauk-Šendorf creeps in on tiptoe and kisses Marty on the neck.

Marty has evidently been expecting her old lover, who racily recounts that his own wife is really much too old for him, that he has managed to steal her jewellery and is now ready to elope with his beloved gypsy girl. Taking a pair of castanets from his pocket he takes a turn or two round, snapping his fingers.

Marty is serious about going away with him: just then, however, there is a general entrance from different quarters as Gregor, Dr. Kolenatý, Vítek and Kristina burst into the room. They are followed by a hospital attendant who gently leads away his patient, the half-crazed Count.

The lawyer and his clerk have been doing some detective work; comparing the signature of Ellian MacGregor on the document supplied by Marty with Marty’s own signature on the photograph she signed for Krista, they have found them to be the handwriting of the same person and have come to demand an explanation.

Thus cornered, Marty opens the drawer of the toilet-table, as Gregor jumps towards her and wrenches a revolver from her hand. Crying out that matters have gone far enough and she is prepared to answer all their questions, she rushes into her bedroom. In her absence the three men decide to take the law into their own hands and search through her belongings.

They find a medallion with Hauk-Šendorf ‘s family crest on it, letters and documents from Eugenia Montez, Elsa Muller, Ellian MacGregor and other of Marty’s aliases. Although reluctant to begin the search, Dr. Kolenatý is at last thoroughly incensed and sends his old clerk to bring him gown and wig, for he is determined to put the fear of God into this shocking woman.

The stage is now set for the final scene of the opera. Dr. Kolenatý is now dressed like a judge: Vítek has also brought some tapers and a crucifix.

Marty staggers in drunk: she has a whisky bottle in one hand and a glass in the other and is elaborately dressed.

Judge and "jury" are appalled and Dr. Kolenatý sternly takes the bottle away from her. (It was Janáček’s idea, not Čapek’s, to make Marty intoxicated at the beginning of her big scene.)

Dr. Kolenatý solemnly begins his interrogation: her name? Elina Makropulos: her birthplace? Crete: her age? "How old do you think? "Kristina suggests that Marty is perhaps in her forties. Sticking out her tongue at her, Marty exclaims: "Oh, you little hussy! "Dr. Kolenatý repeats his question sternly how old is she? Marty replies that, as she was born in 1575, she is 347 years old. Kolenatý is incredulous-she is making a fool of them!

Her father, continues Marty, was doctor and alchemist to Emperor Rudolph II, an emperor who kept seeking for something to keep him young, some kind of potion to prolong his life. Her father discovered the secret. The emperor, however, was too frightened to try it, unless, that is, someone else tried it first. He suggested that the alchemist should experiment on his own 16-year-old daughter. This was done; the daughter fell ill and lay for several days in a coma: seeing this, the emperor arrested her father and had him executed as a fraud. She (the daughter) recovered and escaped to Hungary: when she found she went on living beyond the allotted threescore and ten she felt the necessity constantly to change her identity in order to avoid suspicion.

Thus it turned out that as Ellian MacGregor she was the mistress of Baron Prus, and under five separate names (always with the initials E M.) has lived five separate lives. Only once had she revealed her secret; this was when she gave the prescription to her lover, Baron Prus, in whose house it had remained until this morning.

She has now come to the end of her tether: she must either take another dose of the life elixir or die. Marty collapses and is carried to a couch. For a time Dr. Kolenatý is only half-convinced that she is telling the truth. "She’s fainted, or else is in a state of catalepsy: or if it’s not that, I don’t know what the deuce it can be", he says, still very puzzled at her strange confession.

Then, suddenly, he is convinced: all the pieces of the jigsaw puzzle have fallen into place-no other explanation will cover the facts. The philosophical discussion which follows in the play-where Kristina and the men discuss the pros and cons of an existence prolonged for 300 years compared to a normal life span-is extremely interesting, but was considered by Janáček to be too didactic for operatic treatment.

Now that she finds she is dying, Marty asks herself why it was she was so afraid of death. No one should want to live so long: if they only knew how pleasant and meaningful their shorter lives are: all things have importance for them, are of value: because they must die so soon, life seems full of pleasure: they believe in virtue, greatness, love and even in mankind.

She has no further desire to go on living, although she is afraid to die: nothing has any meaning for her any longer, everything is so futile, singing or silence, wickedness or virtue-it’s all the same to her. "Everything bores me, for, you see, nothing really exists! " Standing on her couch she holds the magic formula at arm’s length and offers it to the company: "Bertik?"-Gregor makes a gesture of refusal. "Well, then, the doctor? "-Kolenatý is of a similar mind. "You have it, Kristina. I stole your sweetheart from you: you’re beautiful, talented, you can be famous and one day you’ll sing like Emilia Marty-come-who’ll take it?"

"Burn it! Burn it!" the four men cry out decidedly. Kristina takes the document from Marty and holds it over the candle flame. As she does so Marty cries out in her mother tongue the first two words of the Lord’s prayer "Pater hemon!" and falls dead having accepted death as the logical end of life, reconciled to an endless sleep which solves all her problems.

The Music of Act III

SCENE 1. PRUS AND MARTY (PP. 135-8)

The two main themes in the opening scene are both associated with Prus-

(a) a motif of remorse and regret

No 66

(b) a motif of fury and anger.

No 67

The latter grows out of an exultant? gigue-like unison passage for violins, where a two-note accompanying figure appears at [3] (which follows on the first appearance of the remorse motif) probably expressing Marty’s excitement at being about to secure the magic formula.

Prus’s agitation, frustration and irritation are all woven into the music [8] to [9], where the silences are as important as the sounds. A curious, elusive figure over mysterious harmonies is heard while Marty examines the faded manuscript [10], followed by Prus’s remorse theme as he reproaches Marty for having cheated him out of it. A trombone and then a trumpet twice give out a nasty, crooked phrase picturing Prus’s utter disgust with himself [13]. The two-note anger motif reappears at [141, when the chamber maid knocks. Prus is ashamed at being found in this compromising situation: violin and viola play the sadly fluttering

No. 68

associated with the excitement of the humble chambermaid. This theme has a bolder appendix to it [17] + 4 of which the end arpeggio group develops (p. 141) as the chambermaid describes to her mistress the terrifying agitation of Prus’s servant. As the distraught Prus returns we hear the heart-rending motif of his grief tear its heart out on the strings.

No. 69

This melody is in fact a powerful variation of the chambermaid’s agitation motif. What was to her merely an exciting piece of news, is to Prus an overwhelming personal tragedy. The sadness and pathos of No. 4 wells through the ensuing scene, while Marty’s reactions appear in the counterpoint, [23] then again at [24] in its own right, expressing Prus’s annoyance at Marty’s lack of interest in the suicide of his son for which he feels she is largely to blame. The two-note figure of No. 67 also cuts in. A4, [25] then a 4 variant [26] of No. 69 evolves (p. 144) until Prus storms out in disgust.

As the half-crazed old Count tiptoes in, the orchestra gives out quietly at [28] a slight little rocking figure derived from Act II, No. 60, followed by the doddering skittish pattern figure at [28] which suggests his inner mirth at eluding his old wife and stealing a march on her by purloining her jewels. As, however, it transpires that the Count has escaped from a mental home, it may well be these adventures are merely imaginary. Marty’s affection for the gentle old fellow is expressed in her: "Si, si, Senor" phrase ([29]+3 and 4) which carries over its expressive contents into the orchestra.

The lilting waltz tune from p. 96 reappears at [33] with the two-note ostinato figure at [28] and persists until Hauk’s hospital attendant arrives and leads him away. Janáček has made considerable cuts in Čapek’s Act III, not the least being the sudden exit of the Count at this point: in the play he has much to say for himself in the cross-examination scene which follows. This scene begins in the opera with a highly dramatic interjection on trombones, tuba and double-basses.

No. 70

Like many other passages in this and other Janáček operas, this interrogation motif is written in the whole-tone scale. Janáček’s use of this primarily impressionist device rarely goes beyond a few measures: subsequent repetitions of the motif align themselves with traditional major and minor keys.

A new twin motif (of accusation?) appears at [40]-5 with side-drum-later timpani-supplying a militant touch to the colour. A more aggressive version of (B) accompanies Gregor’s rather self-conscious reproach of Marty, for the alleged wrong she has done Kristina Incidentally, after

No 71

having his love spurned by Marty, Gregor turns nasty and in the play all but loses the sympathy of the audience when he suggests to the others that they should search through her luggage. The accompanying figure at [45]-2, is immediately worked on its own rights at [45], even generating a new motif of Marty’s despair at [47] .

As the men hurriedly search through Marty’s cases, the orchestra plays over and over again a chop-stick four note figure. An important theme in this episode is the agitated

No. 72

again with whole-tone scale leanings. It is worth noting that a unison stepping up to a major seventh is a frequent progression in the bass in this section of the opera. It may be seen at [57] to [58] and at [25], [28], [38], [66], [70] + 6 and elsewhere.

Marty is half-drunk when she re-enters. Here is how Janáček characterizes her befuddled state

No. 73

 

The two voices of this hysterical theme (A and B) are heard in combination and in alternation particularly the two note figure (C) which is developed at some length from [58] to [66], again at [72] till [77] and lastly between [86] and [90] and [110] and [111]. Dr. Kolenatý asks her what is the name of her father. When she replies that he was Hieronymus Makropulos, horns behind the stage play the trumpet fanfare we heard many times in the overture; when Kolenatý angrily declares that he is through with her for this monstrous lie, trumpets and horns in the orchestra strongly proclaim the truth of her statement. Another set of complimentary motifs appear

No 74

(A) represents Dr. Kolenatý’s scepticism and (B) Marty’s assurance and nonchalance.

A further Marty confession motif is the diatonic No. 10

No 75

The Rudolph fanfare motif reappears at [94] in a new and spritely, buoyant, imitative episode, picturing Marty as a fresh young uninhibited 16-year-old girl at the time when her father was making his great discovery: immediately after, there comes music for the painful, mysterious, suspended-animation coma she fell into after swallowing the drug [97] The two-note figure of enquiry will be seen at [92], [98], and elsewhere. Kolenatý’s theme of Act I reappears at [70]+6 and [102]-3, reminding us that Janáček is not always inattentive to his own thematic material in other acts.

Music of great intensity and emotion is heard when, at the climax of this scene, Marty collapses, is carried out and the men are forced to admit the genuineness of her confession The orchestral interlude at [110] begins with Marty’s hysterical drunken theme preceded and followed by solemn chords on trombones: then a solo violin plays

No 76

which now may be looked upon as Marty’s resignation-to-death theme although it has been prominent in the musical texture between [102] and [109]. It is quoted above in the majestic presentation at [112] where in the Prague production, the revolving stage brings Marty and the couch she is lying on to centre foreground. Theme II (particularly its first part with the question mark *) is the main melody line-up to p. 183 and is accompanied by measured tremolos A new Vision-of-Unreality motif appears after [115]

No 77

as the male chorus echoes or replies to Marty’s philosophical and metaphysical meditations. The passionate No. 78 appears

No. 78

as a positive Contentment-with-God’s-Divine-Plan motif at [117] with its three-note counterpart No. 70 until [21].

No. 79

This new motif of redemption

No. 80

dominates the last few pages of the score from p. 188 to the end. There are high-pitched long, sustained harmonies above it giving a certain ethereal quality to the sound. The oft-repeated yearning figure (A) rises and falls in serene resignation: yet postulating a question as Marty offers the secret of longevity to the assembled company ([124] to [127]). The unanimous opinion is to reject it. Here Janáček achieves a strikingly dramatic stroke, switching over instantaneously from emotional contemplation to direct action at [27].

On two previous occasions at the height of her despair, Marty has prayed fervently to "Pater hemon" (pp. 177 and 178), and her last words in the opera are again a call to her Father in Heaven.

The opera concludes with motif (B) of 80.

Note

On 5 December 1925 Janáček had written to Kamila "I have finished The Makropulos Case-the poor three hundred year old beauty: people took her for a thief, for a liar, for a heartless animal. They called her beast, slut: they wanted to strangle her. And her fault? That she was doomed to live too long a time. I was sorry for her. Three years’ work is at an end. What now?"

The Makropulos Case received its first performance in Brno on 8 December 1926, conducted by František Neumann and produced by Ota Zítek who had collaborated in the première of previous Janáček operas.

In the following year Janáček gave an interview to Adolf Veselý entitled "Capriccio of a Creative Autumn" which appeared in an October issue of Ceske’Slovo. "It was a job that caused me some pain and I had to re-write the libretto three times. Right from the start it gripped me: I felt rather proud of the third act: it flows-there is a feeling of suspense. I spent nearly a year writing this act, but I finally felt that I got what I wanted." The first Prague performance took place on 1 March 1928. For this the author of the play, Karel Čapek, sent a charming little note to the composer in which he wished him another great success, saying modestly that he would attend one of the performances to applaud a great musical work which he had the honour to inspire in a small way.

For a long time The Makropulos Case was considered one of the least successful of the Janáček operas: in recent years, however, it has been reassessed and is now appearing not infrequently on the operatic stages of the world and with increasing popularity. Vogel aptly calls it: "One of the most unreal and yet at the same time most shattering dramas of human existence."


Book Contents page

Chapter 2: page 1 page 2 page 3 page 4

 

Return to: Music on the Web